David and Clara Kasdan found their son on the floor of his Blackthorn Avenue condominium on Wednesday, August 6, 1986. David Kasdan told Canadian Press that Edwin was just inside the front door, face down and fully clothed, and that they saw blood on his face when they turned him over.
Edwin Kasdan, 55, had dinner at his parents’ house every Wednesday night. The Globe and Mail reported that his mother became concerned when she could not reach him at home that morning. Homicide detectives said he had been dead several days. He was last seen on Friday, August 1.
An autopsy showed he had been beaten with a blunt instrument and had died of loss of blood and shock from multiple head injuries. Police found no sign of a break-in or a struggle, and nothing appeared to be missing. The Globe counted him as Metro Toronto’s 25th homicide victim of 1986.

He was buried at Mount Sinai Memorial Park in North York on Thursday, August 7, after a service at Beth Sholom Synagogue. His death notice named his parents and his brother Irving.
Kasdan practised estate law. The Globe reported that he spent nearly ten years in the 1970s in the office of Ontario’s Official Guardian, acting for minors who were beneficiaries of estates. At his death he was a consulting partner at E. L. Stone and Associates on Bay Street, where a spokesman said he also handled landlord-and-tenant cases and general practice. In 1984 the Toronto Star described him as leading a course on wills and estates at The Skills Exchange. He told the paper that many people handle a spouse’s estate themselves, and that with a simple estate, “You save a lot of money.” The only pastime his law partners knew of, the Globe wrote, was his membership in the University of Toronto’s Arts and Letters Club.
Police had charged him before. On the night of Thursday, October 11, 1979, more than 50 Metro police officers raided the Hot Tub Club, a gay bath on Isabella Street, and four other locations. The Star reported that 11 men and one woman were arrested on 26 charges, ranging from keeping a common bawdy house to making obscene films. Kasdan, then 48, was among them. The Star listed his charges: permitting premises to be used as a common bawdy house, keeping a common bawdy house, being an inmate of one, and conspiracy to manufacture obscene material. Inspector James Majury, who led the five-month investigation, said “the majority of people involved were, I would say, homosexual, but not all.” More than 100 people gathered outside the Hot Tub Club to jeer the police.
The Body Politic, a Toronto magazine, reported that police had photographed Kasdan, described as a friend of the club’s apparent owner, through the window of the Empire Diner on Yonge Street. It also reported that officers raided a cottage in Northumberland County near Peterborough. The man looking after the property told the magazine that officers entered without a warrant and that one struck him on the back of the head with a fireplace log.
In 1986 the Star wrote that Kasdan’s “involvement in the homosexual community got him in trouble with police” six years earlier, when he was convicted of permitting his cottage at Hastings, Ontario, to be used as a common bawdy house. The Globe, covering the 1988 trial, said he was convicted in 1980 in connection with making gay pornographic films.

In the first week of the investigation, the coverage leaned on his private life. The Globe called him a 55-year-old bachelor and a “solitary” man. Staff Sergeant Jack Press, who led the investigation, said callers had told police that Kasdan “frequented the downtown area.”
On August 13 the Star reported that police believed Kasdan met his killer in the St. Charles Tavern on Yonge Street north of College Street, after leaving Roy Thomson Hall. On Friday, August 1, he had dined with a friend at a restaurant near King and John streets and then gone to a performance. Police issued a new photograph of him and asked anyone who had seen him after 10:45 p.m. that night to call. The Star added that, according to police, he was well known in Toronto’s homosexual community and was often seen near Yonge and Grosvenor streets.
On August 20 the Star reported that homicide investigators were looking for a teenager who had been with Kasdan on the weekend he was killed. Police had a description of a youth believed to be 17 to 19 years old.
On October 1 police charged a 17-year-old with second-degree murder. He appeared before a provincial court judge at Old City Hall and was remanded. The Young Offenders Act barred the papers from naming him. Because he was 17 at the time, this post refers to him only as E.S. The Globe wrote that investigators had searched for Kasdan’s killer “in downtown homosexual bars he frequented.”
A hearing on whether E.S. should be tried as an adult began on December 1, 1986, under a publication ban. On March 2, 1987, Provincial Court Judge Ayres Couto ruled that he should be. The Star explained that the judge had to weigh the seriousness of the crime, the needs of the accused and the interest of society. The most the Young Offenders Act allowed was three years in secure custody. An adult convicted of second-degree murder faced life imprisonment, with parole eligibility set between 10 and 25 years.
On March 9 E.S. was granted $500 bail. The terms, set by Mr. Justice Jean-Charles Sirois of the Ontario Supreme Court, included supervision by the Toronto Bail Program and a daily curfew from 10 p.m. to 7 a.m. The Crown asked the Ontario Court of Appeal to revoke the bail. On April 3 the court refused, unanimously, finding that the public was adequately protected by the “very strict terms” Sirois had set. E.S.’s lawyer, David Cole, told the court that an appeal of the transfer to adult court was set for June 2.
E.S., then 19, went on trial in the Ontario Supreme Court on Wednesday, March 23, 1988, before Mr. Justice John O’Driscoll and a jury of ten men and two women. He pleaded not guilty. In her opening statement, assistant Crown attorney Kathryn Hawke told the jury that Kasdan had been struck 23 times in the head with a heavy glass ashtray. “The killing was an intentional, brutal and one-sided attack,” she said. The Toronto Sun reported that Hawke described Kasdan as a known homosexual who “sought people to be involved with.” Later reports gave the number of blows as 24.
Hawke said a friend of Kasdan’s saw him with E.S. on August 2, the first day of a three-day holiday weekend. E.S. was living then at Seaton House, a men’s residence on George Street. Randy Newell, a Toronto Transit Commission driver, testified that just before 3 p.m. on Monday, August 4, a teenager “maybe 17 years old” boarded his Eglinton Avenue West bus near Kasdan’s home. Both of the teenager’s hands were bandaged, with blood showing at the edges. Hawke told the jury that blood matching E.S.’s type was found in the apartment and that later on August 4 he went to Toronto General Hospital, where his hands were operated on.
Police witnesses described the apartment. Sergeant Jerry Kocher said there was a noticeable smell of a dead body and no sign of ransacking, and the Sun reported a trail of blood from the bedroom. Sergeant Ian Mann testified that pieces of the ashtray lay in the living room and bedroom and that the bed was dotted with blood and glass. Blood-splattered towels and clothing were in the bedroom and bathroom, and it appeared someone had cleaned up in the bathroom without trying to hide it. A pair of jeans too small for Kasdan lay on the bed. Mann said there was no evidence of forcible entry, robbery or ransacking, and that two sets of fingerprints matching E.S.’s were on the kitchen table. Forensic biologist Robert White testified that blood was spattered on the wall above the bed. The Globe reported that police also found a number of gay “soft porn” videos in the apartment.
David Bowker, a friend of E.S., testified that he visited him at Hillcrest Hospital that August, when both his hands were in casts. Bowker said E.S. told him he had been at a man’s house, hit someone over the head with a crystal ashtray and killed someone, without saying who. Constable David Lear testified that E.S. gave different reasons for his injured hands. He said he broke them on a window, on machinery at George Brown College, and by trying to commit suicide.
E.S. testified on March 25. He said he struck Kasdan repeatedly with a glass ashtray because he feared for his life, and that Kasdan tried to rape and choke him. He told the jury he had recently moved to Toronto from Timmins and was living at a downtown men’s hostel. He said he met Kasdan in Allan Gardens two days before Kasdan died, took him for “an outgoing person” and accepted his invitations because he was lonely. He said Kasdan told him he was a lawyer. E.S. testified that he was not a homosexual, that another man had propositioned him in the same park earlier, and that there was no sign Kasdan was a homosexual until the incident that led to his death.
The Star reported E.S.’s account of the morning of August 4. He said Kasdan had invited him to sleep on the living room couch the night before. Kasdan called him into the bedroom, threw him on the bed and held a forearm across his throat while trying to undo his pants. The Star quoted E.S. as saying Kasdan told him, “I want to get it into you.” E.S. said he grabbed the ashtray and hit Kasdan on the head. He said he reached a telephone but Kasdan stopped him, and that when he ran for the front door Kasdan grabbed his shirt and pulled him back. He said he was in shock, afraid Kasdan would rape and kill him, and wanted only to knock him out. When he realized Kasdan was dead, he said, he changed out of his bloody clothes into some of Kasdan’s and went to the hospital.
On Monday, March 28, a 23-year-old man who said he had worked as a male prostitute testified that Kasdan paid him for sex several times, beginning in 1981. He said Kasdan asked him in early 1986 to move in and do household duties, and that he refused because violence seemed to excite Kasdan. “I was nervous around him,” he said. The Star headlined its report “Lawyer violent in sex acts, murder trial told.” The Globe’s headline read “Lawyer excited by violence, witness tells murder trial.”
In his address to the jury, Cole called Kasdan a predator “in search of prey” when he befriended E.S. in the park. He described E.S. as a “naive young teen-ager” who killed in self-defence. He said Kasdan had pornographic books in his apartment and had been convicted in connection with the filming of a pornographic show. The defence relied on Kasdan’s sexuality and sexual history. The jury heard about his 1980 conviction and the videos in his apartment. It also heard a man he had paid for sex describe him as violent.
Hawke told the jury there was nothing to suggest a two-way fight at any point. “It was one-sided and it was intentional,” she said. E.S. had no other injuries, and his clothes were not torn. She said it was unbelievable that Kasdan would keep up the attack after being hit repeatedly on the head. E.S. changed his clothes and cleaned himself up before leaving, she said, which showed he was not disoriented. He also made little effort to check on Kasdan afterward, and he gave conflicting explanations for his injuries to police and hospital officials. The Star reported that she told the jury E.S. had a selective memory.
The jury deliberated for six hours. On the night of Wednesday, March 30, it found E.S. not guilty of second-degree murder. He broke down and cried. “It was too good to be true,” he said outside the courtroom. He said he felt sympathy for Kasdan’s elderly parents. A pathologist had told the court that Kasdan, who weighed 72 kilograms, suffered a large skull fracture. E.S. weighed about 59 kilograms and had severe injuries to his hands. A friend described him as non-violent, and he had no criminal record.
The Globe’s verdict story identified E.S. as “not a homosexual” and Kasdan as a homosexual, and it repeated the 1980 conviction and the videos found in his apartment.
The papers disagree on small points. The Crown’s opening gave 23 blows, and later reports gave 24. One paper said his parents expected him for dinner on a Tuesday night; the others said Wednesday.
Vital statistics
| Field | Detail |
|---|---|
| Name | Edwin Howard Kasdan |
| Age | 55 (single reports gave 59 and 65) |
| Gender | Male |
| Occupation | Estate lawyer; consulting partner, E. L. Stone and Associates, Bay Street |
| Date of death | August 4, 1986 (body found August 6) |
| Manner of death | Blunt force; struck with a glass ashtray, 23 or 24 times |
| Location | Blackthorn Avenue condominium, City of York |
| Accused | E.S., 17 at the time of the killing |
| Charge | Second-degree murder |
| Defence counsel | David Cole |
| Crown counsel | Kathryn Hawke, assistant Crown attorney |
| Judge | Mr. Justice John O’Driscoll, Ontario Supreme Court |
| Verdict | Not guilty, March 30, 1988 |
Sources
- The Toronto Star, October 12, 1979, p. A3
- The Body Politic, no. 58, November 1979, pp. 8–9
- The Toronto Star, July 31, 1984, p. H1
- The Toronto Star, November 26, 1984, p. D1
- The Globe and Mail, August 7, 1986, p. A15
- The Lethbridge Herald, August 7, 1986, p. 20 (Canadian Press)
- The Toronto Star, August 7, 1986, p. H1 (death notice and funeral listing)
- The Globe and Mail, August 8, 1986, p. A11
- The Toronto Star, August 13, 1986, p. A15
- The Toronto Star, August 20, 1986, p. D24
- The Globe and Mail, October 2, 1986, p. A16
- The Toronto Star, December 2, 1986, p. D12
- The Globe and Mail, March 3, 1987, p. A18
- The Toronto Star, March 3, 1987, p. A22
- The Globe and Mail, March 10, 1987, p. A17
- The Toronto Star, March 11, 1987, p. A7
- The Globe and Mail, April 4, 1987, p. C7
- Toronto Sun, March 24, 1988
- The Globe and Mail, March 24, 1988, p. A17
- The Toronto Star, March 25, 1988, p. B7
- The Globe and Mail, March 26, 1988, p. A15
- The Globe and Mail, March 29, 1988, p. A15
- The Toronto Star, March 29, 1988, p. A28
- The Globe and Mail, March 31, 1988, p. A14
- JewishGen Online Worldwide Burial Registry, Mount Sinai Memorial Park, North York, 1986
Murder Village Map