On the afternoon of Wednesday, February 13, 1991, Toronto police went to a house on Thorncliffe Avenue, near Danforth and Broadview Avenues. Relatives and friends had reported that Norman John Cardwell had failed to show up for work. Police found him dead, shot in the head.
Cardwell was 51, a salesman born in Toronto. Neighbours told the Toronto Star he had moved into the house about 20 years earlier and had lived alone since a recent divorce. His two children, aged 10 and 13, often visited him. The Star and the Globe and Mail both counted him as Metro’s fourteenth homicide victim of 1991.

An autopsy the next day confirmed that a bullet had caused the head wound. Det. Sgt. Vic Matanovic, who headed the investigation, released few details. He said police were still trying to determine whether there had been a robbery, and he asked for help tracing Cardwell’s movements in his last hours.
The Star published a death notice on February 16. It listed him as the father of two, the son of Phyllis and the late Norman Cardwell, and the brother of Brian. Friends could call at the Ralph Coy Funeral Home on Danforth Avenue on Sunday, with a service in the chapel on Monday.
On Monday, February 25, police released photographs of a man the Star described as either the suspect or someone who knew the killer. Det. Doug Grady said the pictures came from a video taken soon after Cardwell was shot, and that the man was believed to be the last person to see Cardwell alive. Grady said police did not know how well the man knew Cardwell, or whether he knew him at all. They put his age at about 27. Grady also gave Cardwell’s last known movements: he was seen in the late afternoon of February 11, walking around the rear of his car, apparently alone, after a 4 p.m. appointment with his bank manager.
According to evidence at his later trial, Ronald Arthur Cooney, 28, was drinking on the night of March 14 with a friend, Troy McIlvenna. The Globe and Mail reported that the conversation took place in a Belleville bar. The Ontario Court of Appeal later summarized McIlvenna’s evidence this way: Cooney said he and a friend, Darryl Marsh, had placed an ad in a “fag” magazine to lure a homosexual victim. He said he took the man’s bank card, frightened him into giving up the PIN, and shot him four times in the head. He said he threw the gun, which had been “cut up”, into the lake.
The Court of Appeal said Cooney left Toronto for Eastern Ontario after he saw one of the photographs in the Toronto Sun, which had asked readers to call police if they recognized the man. Police arrested him on Saturday, March 23. The Star reported on March 25 that Cooney, 28, of Cleethorpes Boulevard in Scarborough, had been charged with first-degree murder and remanded in custody. The Globe and Mail ran a brief on the same charge that day, without naming him. The Star added what police now said had happened. A man had entered Cardwell’s home that evening, drawn a gun and shot him in the head. The killer had robbed him before fleeing.
On April 1, the Star counted 25 homicides in Metro in the first three months of 1991. It had counted 53 in all of 1990. The homicide squad was scrambling to train more detectives. In the Star’s list of the year’s victims, Cardwell was “just recently divorced.” The Star wrote that police found signs of a robbery but suspected he “may have unwittingly brought his assailant back to his apartment.”
Marsh was found dead at the foot of the Scarborough Bluffs while Cooney was in custody. The Star put the date in May 1991. The Globe and Mail reported that an autopsy could not precisely determine how he died. The Star reported that the court was told the cause was believed to be poisoning from an ingredient commonly found in headache tablets. One Globe and Mail report said it was an acetaminophen overdose. The Court of Appeal wrote that Marsh committed suicide before trial.
Cooney’s trial opened in early June 1992 before Madam Justice Patricia German and a jury in the Ontario Court (General Division). It ran eight weeks. Crown prosecutor John Scutt told the jury that Cooney had said to a friend in a Belleville bar: “I shot him four times.” Scutt said police had withheld the fact that Cardwell was shot four times in the head. He said the evidence would show that Cardwell answered an ad Cooney placed in NOW magazine seeking male companionship. Cooney pleaded not guilty. His lawyer was James Lockyer.
The Court of Appeal summarized the rest of the Crown’s case. Cardwell was found in the basement. He had been shot four times at short range, probably with a .22 calibre rifle with a sawed-off barrel. There were marks on his wrist consistent with handcuffs and a bruise on his forehead from a blow of significant force. He had no defensive wounds. His wallet was in the kitchen and his Toronto-Dominion bank card was missing. Letters in his briefcase indicated that he was bisexual and had arranged meetings with men through classified ads on at least two earlier occasions. The issue of NOW dated January 31 to February 6 carried an ad in which a young male, “extremely attractive”, sought an “older professional” and gave a box number. The court noted evidence that Cardwell had sexual activity before his death, and said there was no suggestion it was not consensual.
There was evidence that Cooney rented the box and placed the ad under a false name. Cooney had once owned handcuffs and had bought a .22 AR-7 rifle in December 1990. The gun was never recovered. Cardwell’s card was used at Toronto-Dominion machines at eight locations over four days after the killing, and bank cameras photographed Cooney.
Cooney testified in July. He denied any part in the robbery or the killing and said he was at home with his brother. He said he bought the rifle but gave it to Marsh. He said Marsh came to him that night with Cardwell’s card and a PIN on a piece of paper, saying he had taken the wallet from a man he met in a bar. Cooney said he went with Marsh to the machines only because Marsh did not know how to use one. He said he learned on February 16 that the card belonged to the dead man, threw it back at Marsh and told him he no longer wanted to be his friend. The Globe and Mail reported that Cooney admitted withdrawing about $300 with the card, and that on one occasion he used the cash to buy roses for his girlfriend, an exotic dancer. Its sentencing report put the figure at $500.

On the ad, the accounts differ. The Globe and Mail reported at sentencing that Cooney admitted placing it but said he did so for Marsh. The Court of Appeal’s summary has him admitting that he rented the box under a false name Marsh gave him, while saying he knew nothing of Marsh’s plan to place an ad. Cooney also denied the barroom confession. He said he and McIlvenna were drunk and McIlvenna had misunderstood him. Defence counsel told the jury that if it accepted McIlvenna’s evidence, the only verdict open was first-degree murder. The Court of Appeal wrote that Crown and defence appeared to agree that probably only one person was at the scene. The Crown said it was Cooney. The defence said it was Marsh.
On cross-examination, the Crown suggested that Cooney was a man with “mixed sexual preferences” who took out the ad to meet a closet gay man. The Globe and Mail’s court briefs called Cardwell “a gay Toronto man.” The Star wrote that Cooney and Marsh had advertised for “a closet homosexual.” The defence theory, as the papers and the Court of Appeal report it, was that Marsh was the killer, and Marsh could no longer answer.
The jury returned its verdict on Friday, July 31, 1992. It found Cooney guilty of manslaughter. The Star reported that Cooney showed no reaction. Newspaper accounts of how long the jury deliberated range from two days to four.

Madam Justice German sentenced Cooney to 12 years on October 6, 1992. The Globe and Mail reported that she saw the verdict only as an indication that the Crown had not proven Cooney’s presence at the scene beyond a reasonable doubt. Lockyer described the verdict as a rejection both of the Crown’s theory that Cooney was the killer and of any suggestion that he was in the house. The Star reported that German said Cooney could have prevented the killing and was involved in planning the robbery. She said she would have sentenced him to 15 years had he not spent so long in custody before trial. She said, in the Star’s report, “the jury was not satisfied he (Cooney) did the killing.” The Globe and Mail quoted her on “the random way in which the victim was selected.”
The papers framed the victim in different terms. The Star described a man who insisted that a friend “murdered a stranger during a bungled robbery.” The Globe and Mail described a businessman who “responded to an advertisement seeking companionship from a ‘closet’ gay.”
Cooney appealed the sentence. On April 7, 1995, the Ontario Court of Appeal reduced it to eight years. Justice Finlayson, with Justice Laskin agreeing, found that the trial judge should have decided what role the verdict implied for Cooney. He concluded that the jury was not satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that Cooney was the killer or was present. He cited Cooney’s youth, his minimal criminal record, his time in pretrial custody and his performance in the penitentiary. Justice Galligan dissented. He found that the jury had decided Cooney was present and took part in the robbery. He wrote that the killing “appears to have been a virtual execution,” and he would have kept the 12 years.
Vital statistics
| Field | Detail |
|---|---|
| Name | Norman John Cardwell |
| Born | Toronto |
| Age | 51 |
| Gender | Male |
| Occupation | Salesman (the Globe and Mail also called him a businessman) |
| Date of death | February 11, 1991; body found February 13 (the Court of Appeal gives February 14) |
| Manner of death | Shot four times in the head |
| Location | 9 Thorncliffe Avenue, Toronto |
| Accused | Ronald Arthur Cooney, 28 at arrest, 29 at trial, of Scarborough |
| Charge | First-degree murder |
| Defence counsel | James Lockyer |
| Crown counsel | John Scutt |
| Judge | Madam Justice Patricia German, Ontario Court (General Division) |
| Verdict | Manslaughter, July 31, 1992 |
| Sentence | 12 years, October 6, 1992; reduced to eight years on appeal, April 7, 1995 |
Sources
- The Globe and Mail, February 15, 1991, p. A9
- Toronto Star, February 15, 1991, p. A6
- Toronto Star, February 16, 1991, p. D7
- Toronto Star, February 26, 1991, p. A6
- The Globe and Mail, March 25, 1991, p. A6
- Toronto Star, March 25, 1991, p. A2
- Toronto Star, April 1, 1991, p. A6
- The Globe and Mail, June 3, 1992, p. A15
- The Globe and Mail, July 16, 1992, p. A15
- The Globe and Mail, July 17, 1992, p. A11
- The Globe and Mail, July 18, 1992, p. A11
- The Globe and Mail, August 1, 1992, p. A8
- Toronto Star, August 1, 1992, p. A5
- The Globe and Mail, October 7, 1992, p. A14
- Toronto Star, October 7, 1992, p. E8
- R. v. Cooney (R.) (1995), 80 O.A.C. 89 (Ont. C.A.), April 7, 1995
- Photograph: Scarborough Bluffs, Alan Dunlop, 1985
Murder Village Map
Norm was a good family man and neighbour. His house has been a half-way house ever since; on occasion bringing trouble to the very quiet neighbourhood.
Statistics never tell the true story. He was a gem. Educated, elegant, kind to a fault, caring. RIP, I am so sorry.
Thinking of kind sweet Norm. Little Annie from up the street.
Thank you for your kind comment about my dad
My dad was a gem. Thank you