Christine Lavery Clifford – Acquittal

Police were called to a ninth-floor apartment on Gilder Drive in Scarborough at about 11 p.m. on Friday, January 6, 1984. The Toronto Star reported later that they found Christine Clifford, 29, with several stab wounds in her abdomen. Alanna (Maume) Smith, 25, who lived in the apartment, was unconscious on the couch.

Clifford was taken to Scarborough General Hospital. She died about three hours after the attack, during surgery. The apartment was in an Ontario Housing Corporation building in the Eglinton and Midland Aves. area. The Star reported on January 8 that an autopsy showed she had been stabbed several times in the abdomen. It was Metro’s first homicide of 1984.

The Star described Clifford as “of no fixed address.” Staff Sgt. Ed Stewart of the Metro police homicide squad said police were working to learn more about her background. Police were questioning several people and still searching for the weapon. “We haven’t yet ruled out anything in the investigation,” Stewart said on Saturday night, January 7.

Scarborough General Hospital where Christine Clifford died

A second woman who had been in the apartment, not yet named by police, was in hospital with a drug overdose and slashed wrists.

On January 11 the Star reported that Winnifred Lynn Kennedy, 29, of Falstaff Avenue in North York, had been charged with second-degree murder.

Kennedy came to trial in County Court in November 1984 before Judge Karen Weiler. The trial ran nine days. The Star reported that Kennedy had pleaded not guilty to manslaughter. She had originally been charged with second-degree murder.

On Monday, November 19, Smith testified. The Star called Clifford and Kennedy her “two live-in lesbian lovers.” Smith told the court she was despondent on January 6 because Kennedy had said she was leaving for Vancouver the next day. The three women had been drinking together at a tavern. When they got back to the apartment, Smith took a handful of pills. She said she was too high on pills and alcohol to remember how Clifford died.

Smith testified that she and Kennedy were making love in the bedroom when Clifford came in, took a whip and began to strike her. She said she enjoyed being whipped at times but that Clifford did not do it well. She said Clifford was jealous of Kennedy, who was her most recent lover, and that the women had argued about it.

On Tuesday, November 20, the court heard Kennedy’s statement to Stewart. She said all three women had been drinking with a neighbour at a tavern that night, then returned to the apartment, picked up Smith’s two-year-old son from nursery school and kept drinking at home. Smith passed out in the living room from alcohol and pills. Clifford was asleep. The neighbour was playing with the boy. Kennedy said she passed out on Smith’s waterbed. When she woke, Smith was still unconscious and the child was pointing to the balcony door. Clifford was on the balcony, bleeding from a stab wound in the abdomen. Kennedy told police the blood on her clothes came from trying to revive her. She said Smith had cut her wrists because Kennedy was leaving for Vancouver.

Other evidence came out over the nine days. Both Kennedy and Smith had told police that a man named Dave was to come to the apartment that night to watch a “lesbian show” the women were to perform for money. Neither could recall whether he arrived. Neighbours said they heard a man and woman arguing in the apartment at about the time Clifford was stabbed. No one was seen. The Crown said Kennedy gave police four different statements. At first she said she did not know Clifford and had not gone to the apartment until after the killing.

On Thursday, November 22, Kennedy’s lawyer, Ken Murray, told the judge that Smith should also be considered a suspect. He said Smith had the opportunity and the motive. She wanted Clifford out of the apartment, Murray said, because she had fallen in love with Kennedy. He noted that Smith had a criminal record for violence, including a conviction for assault with a knife.

Assistant crown attorney Kingsley Wijesinha said his theory was that Kennedy used the knife. The Crown’s case was that Kennedy and Clifford had been vying for Smith’s affections. Wijesinha said Smith may have known of the killing and conspired in it. He pointed to the neighbour, Fred Hayman, who testified that when he left the apartment Smith and Clifford had passed out on two living-room couches, and Kennedy was on the telephone. She had already eaten dinner with the boy. The Crown said nothing proved Kennedy had passed out, and that all the evidence showed she was not drunk. He asked how she could “so conveniently pass out just before the stabbing” and wake up after it. Weiler reserved judgment.

The Crown’s theory and the defence’s theory rested on the same triangle. Each named a different woman as the one with a reason to want Clifford gone. The Star’s account of the verdict opened by describing Kennedy as a woman “involved in a lesbian love triangle” who had been acquitted of killing “her rival.” Its January reports had said nothing about the women’s relationships.

On Friday, November 23, Weiler acquitted Kennedy. She said she could not find, “despite the suspicious circumstances,” that Kennedy stabbed Clifford. “I feel that there were other people who were with the accused that night,” she said, and she added that they had not been charged and had not told the entire truth.

Kennedy broke into tears in the prisoner’s box. “Thank you, your honor,” she cried as she ran from the courtroom.

The record disagrees with itself in places. The Star reported on January 8 that Clifford died after being stabbed several times in the abdomen and that she died during surgery. Its November 24 report said she had six stab wounds to her chest and back and that she was found dead on the balcony. Smith’s first name appears as Alanna in most reports and as Elana in one. The Star’s trial reports of November 20, 21 and 24 give the charge as manslaughter. Its November 23 report refers to second-degree murder.

Vital statistics

FieldDetail
NameChristine Lavery Clifford
Age29
GenderFemale
Date of deathJanuary 6, 1984
Manner of deathStabbed: several wounds to the abdomen (Star, January 8, 1984); six wounds to the chest and back (Star, November 24, 1984)
LocationNinth-floor apartment, Ontario Housing Corporation building, Gilder Dr., Eglinton and Midland Aves. area, Scarborough
AccusedWinnifred Lynn Kennedy, 29, of Falstaff Ave., North York
ChargeSecond-degree murder; tried on manslaughter (the Star’s November 23 report gives second-degree murder)
Defence counselKen Murray
Crown counselKingsley Wijesinha, assistant crown attorney
JudgeCounty Court Judge Karen Weiler
VerdictNot guilty, November 23, 1984

Sources

  • Toronto Star, January 8, 1984, p. A4
  • Toronto Star, January 11, 1984, p. A7
  • Toronto Star, November 20, 1984, p. A14
  • Toronto Star, November 21, 1984, p. A24
  • Toronto Star, November 23, 1984, p. A19
  • Toronto Star, November 24, 1984, p. A17


Murder Village Map

 

 

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.