Eleven months after the stabbing, Assistant Crown Attorney Karen Dunlop told an Ontario Supreme Court jury that on the night of December 20, 1984, Joyce Lorraine Filshie banged on a neighbour’s door and cried, “Come quickly! I’ve stabbed Phil!” Dunlop said Joyce had blood on her hands and that a bloodstained knife lay on the kitchen floor. When police arrived, the court was told, they found Joyce crouched over Phillip’s body.
Phillip Robert Filshie, 51, a warehouse manager, was dead on arrival at Centenary Hospital in Scarborough. The Toronto Star reported the next day that he had been knifed in the chest at his Kingston Road townhouse, near Markham Road, after a domestic dispute. It called him a 51-year-old Scarborough man and called Joyce, 47, his common-law wife. Police had arrested her and charged her with second-degree murder. The paper counted it as Metro Toronto’s 56th homicide of the year.
Joyce went to trial in November 1985. Dunlop told the jury that Phillip was born female, as Barbara Filshie, and that he had married and had a daughter. He later took a man’s name legally. In 1976 he began a common-law relationship with Joyce. Dunlop said he had gone through the first phases of what the Star called a sex-change operation. His daughter, Cindy-Lou, learned only after his death, the court was told, that the person she called her father was her mother.

Homicide squad Sergeant John Barbour testified that Joyce told police the change was not something Phillip had jumped into. He had been seeing a doctor at the Clarke Institute of Psychiatry for a long time. She also told Barbour it had not been completed.
The Clarke has been known since 1998 as the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health. It ran Toronto’s gender identity clinic. In 1998 the American writer Dallas Denny called the Clarke the only institution able to authorize sex reassignment surgery under Canada’s public health system, and accused it of coercing the people it assessed. In an essay drafted in 2008, Astrid Idlewild, drawing on Viviane Namaste’s research, described the clinic’s practice in the 1990s. It asked for a documented year or more of what it counted as legitimate work before prescribing hormones, and it did not count sex work. Both writers were describing the clinic after Phillip’s death.
Brenda Pearce, 29, Joyce’s daughter, testified that her mother told her the stabbing was self-defence. She agreed with defence lawyer Mike Moldaver that it happened while Phillip was pounding Joyce on the back of the head with his fists.
Joyce testified on November 19. She said she had no intention of harming Phillip. They had argued, she said, and Phillip began bashing her on the head. She grabbed a knife to keep him away, and the knife accidentally punctured him when she turned around. She told the jury that she and Phillip loved and cared for each other very much and lived as husband and wife.
Pathologist John Hillsdon Smith told the jury that chest scars showed Phillip’s breasts had been surgically removed. He gave Phillip’s height as five feet four and a half inches and his weight as about 147 pounds, and described him as quite muscular, with a beard, a moustache and considerable body hair. Smith said an accidental stabbing was possible. But after thirty years in the work, he said, no knife wound he had examined had ever persuaded him it was accidental.

Cindy-Lou Thibodeau, 29, told the jury she was devastated to learn that Joyce was not her natural mother and was still trying to come to terms with it. She described Phillip as stubborn, argumentative and unaffectionate, a man who raised his voice a lot and could not be reasoned with.
On November 20, Moldaver told the jury that Joyce picked up the knife to defend herself while Phillip pounded on her head, and that she believed her life was in danger. He said the stabbing was an accident and that she never meant to harm the person she loved. Dunlop argued that Joyce acted recklessly and used excessive force. Chief Justice William Parker was to give the jury its final instructions the next day.
On November 21, the jury of six men and six women deliberated for less than three hours and found Joyce not guilty. She burst into tears, hugged her friends and thanked God, twice, as she spoke to Moldaver. One friend called the verdict a Christmas present.
The Star’s language about Phillip changed between the first report and the trial. On December 21, 1984, he was a man and Joyce was his common-law wife. In November 1985 one headline called him a woman who had undergone a sex change, and the verdict headline framed the case as a sex-change killing. The reports used she and her for Phillip, said he was born a woman and gave birth to a daughter, and set Joyce’s description of him as her common-law husband against what the paper presented as the facts. They itemised his body, from his height and weight to his beard and his removed breasts, and the verdict report added the pathologist’s testimony that he still had a vagina when he died. The defence case, as the Star reported it, was that Phillip attacked Joyce and the stabbing was an accident.
Michael Moldaver, called Mike in the Star, had been called to the Ontario bar in 1973 and practised criminal and civil litigation until his appointment to the bench in 1990. He later sat on the Court of Appeal for Ontario and, from 2011 to 2022, the Supreme Court of Canada.
The record varies on some details. The Star’s first report gave Phillip’s name as Phillip Robert-Filshie, and the trial reports as Phillip Robert Filshie; a Transgender Day of Remembrance display spells it Philip. Cindy-Lou appears as Cindy-Lou Filshie, 28, in one report and as Cindy-Lou Thibodeau, 29, in two others. The first report put the knife in Phillip’s chest. Moldaver told the jury it entered his side.
Vital statistics
| Field | Detail |
|---|---|
| Name | Phillip Robert Filshie (also spelled Philip; named Barbara Filshie before he changed his name, per the Crown) |
| Age | 51 |
| Gender | Male |
| Occupation | Warehouse manager |
| Date of death | December 20, 1984 |
| Manner of death | Stabbed (chest, per the Star’s first report; side, per the defence at trial) |
| Location | Kingston Road townhouse near Markham Road, Scarborough |
| Accused | Joyce Lorraine Filshie, 47 (48 at trial) |
| Charge | Second-degree murder |
| Defence counsel | Michael (Mike) Moldaver |
| Crown counsel | Karen Dunlop, Assistant Crown Attorney |
| Judge | Chief Justice William Parker |
| Verdict | Not guilty, November 21, 1985 |
Sources
- Toronto Star, December 21, 1984, p. A18
- Toronto Star, November 19, 1985, p. A31
- Toronto Star, November 20, 1985, p. F15
- Toronto Star, November 21, 1985, p. H15
- Toronto Star, November 22, 1985, p. C20
- Dallas Denny, The Clarke Institute of Psychiatry: Canada’s shame, Transgender Forum, April 13, 1998
- Astrid Idlewild, Predation and the culture of institutionalization: impacts of perception and placement, Accozzaglia, part 3 of Hostile Homewood (drafted 2008, posted June 15, 2016)
- UC Riverside LGBT Resource Center, Transgender Day of Remembrance display (entry for Philip Robert Filshie)
- Photograph: Clarke Institute of Psychiatry Gender Identity Clinic, College Street at Huron: Mateen Mahboubi
- On Michael Moldaver: https://scc-csc.ca/about-apropos/judges-juges/list-liste/michael-j-moldaver ; https://www.canada.ca/en/department-justice/news/2022/09/statement-from-the-minister-of-justice-and-attorney-general-of-canada-on-the-retirement-of-supreme-court-justice-michael-moldaver.html
Murder Village Map
*We include Philip’s birth name for genealogical searches.