Paul Armstrong – Dumped and Burned

On Monday, December 16, 1996, employees at an industrial complex on McLevin Avenue in Scarborough noticed that someone had apparently set a fire in one of the dumpsters, the Globe and Mail reported. The Toronto Star described a smouldering dumpster in the Sheppard Avenue East and Markham Road area. The body inside was burned beyond recognition. It took three days to determine the victim’s sex and age.

Black and white photo of murder victim Paul Armstrong
Murder victim Paul Armstrong

On Thursday, December 19, police identified the dead man from dental records. He was Paul Armstrong, 37, a social worker who lived on Leverhume Crescent in Scarborough.

Armstrong had left the house at about 11 a.m. on Saturday, December 14. He was expected back that night for a small party he was holding for a few friends. He did not come. The Star reported that he did not take his car, and that police believed he left in someone else’s. His mother, Evelyn Armstrong, told the Star that boarders at the house heard him leave but did not see the driver.

Armstrong did not show up for work at St. Joseph’s Health Centre on Monday, where, the Star reported, he counselled “mentally handicapped patients.” His roommates reported him missing to police that day. A roommate also phoned his family in Trenton to say he was missing. By then his body had been found.

On Friday, December 20, Detective Ray Zarb of homicide told the Globe and Mail that the autopsy had found no obvious cause of death and that further tests were under way. “This is not a murder at this point,” he said. “It’s still being treated as a suspicious death.”

The Globe reported that homicide detectives were seeking help from Metropolitan Toronto’s gay community. Zarb said Armstrong was known to be part of that community. Police wanted to hear from anyone who had seen him, or had been near 150 McLevin Avenue between Sunday evening and Monday morning.

150 McLevin Avenue where murder victim Paul Armstrong was found
150 McLevin Avenue where murder victim Paul Armstrong was found

The Star ran its story the same day under the headline “Burned body baffles police” and called Armstrong “a quiet social worker.” Zarb told the Star that his disappearance was “completely out of character.” He said Armstrong “did not have an active social life.” The Star reported that, as far as investigators knew, Armstrong had no partner and “led a quiet life.” A neighbour told the paper that Armstrong and his roommates had moved into the house in August and kept to themselves. The Star noted that police had not officially labelled the death a homicide.

Armstrong grew up in Trenton, Ontario. According to the Star, he graduated from Trenton High School and studied television broadcasting at Loyalist College. He worked as an audio-visual technician at Moira Secondary School in Belleville. In the late 1970s he moved west to work for the CBC station in Lloydminster, Saskatchewan, and in the early 1980s he took a job at a television station in North Bay. He then left broadcasting, attended York University and earned a master’s degree in social work at the University of Toronto. He worked at a boys’ home and at a downtown crisis centre helping the homeless, drug addicts and street kids, and he helped with a needle-exchange program.

On Tuesday, December 24, the Star reported that robbery had been offered as a possible motive. Police said they would check whether a break-in at the Leverhume Crescent house several weeks earlier was connected. Evelyn Armstrong said police thought he had been lured away. “He was a bit too trusting,” she said.

His parents, Philip and Evelyn Armstrong, described a “sensitive and very bright” son who paid his own way through college and university with summer jobs. “My son was the best,” Philip Armstrong said. His brother Bob said Paul “always thought of other people first.” The funeral home had received many calls from Armstrong’s friends in Toronto. The family had wanted a private service, Philip Armstrong said, and decided to let the friends say goodbye. The Star photographed the family at the funeral in Trenton.

Armstrong had a twin sister, Mary Perras. The Star reported that December 24 was her 38th birthday, the first she had spent without him. He would have come home that day, she said, and they would have celebrated together on Christmas Eve. “We won’t be celebrating anything now,” she said.

No arrest was reported. In June 2018, while police were investigating Bruce McArthur, the National Post reviewed 186 unsolved Toronto homicides from 1975 to 1997 and narrowed them, with input from a police source, to 22 that resembled the pattern of the McArthur killings. Armstrong was one of the 22. The Post wrote that police had said most of the cold cases they were examining involved gay men. It compared the burning of Armstrong’s body and its disposal in a dumpster with the way McArthur was alleged to have hidden remains. It also reported that there was no evidence connecting any of the cold cases to McArthur.

The Toronto Police Service lists the death in its cold case files as Homicide #53/1996. The file records an emergency call to 150 McLevin Avenue at about 7:55 p.m. on December 16. It says the victim was found outside an industrial premises, “suffering from medical trauma” and obviously deceased. The case is unsolved.

Vital statistics

FieldDetail
NamePaul Armstrong
Age37
GenderMale
OccupationSocial worker
Date of deathNot stated; last seen December 14, 1996; body found December 16, 1996
Manner of deathUndetermined in December 1996 reports; listed by Toronto police as Homicide #53/1996
LocationDumpster behind an industrial complex, 150 McLevin Avenue, Scarborough

Sources

  • Photograph: Sal Sacco for the Toronto Star (funeral, Trenton)
  • The Globe and Mail, December 21, 1996, p. A9
  • Toronto Star, December 21, 1996, p. A20
  • Toronto Star, December 24, 1996, p. A4
  • Toronto Police Service, Cold Case Files, Homicide #53/1996
  • National Post (online), June 15, 2018

Murder Village Map

 

 

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.