Duncan William Robinson – A Strange, Hollow Sound

On Tuesday, November 28, 1978, Duncan Robinson failed to turn up for work for the second day in a row. His sister, Catherine, asked police to check on him. Officers forced their way into his apartment on Vaughan Rd. and found his body in the bedroom. Toronto police records give the time of the call as about 2:08 p.m.

He had been stabbed repeatedly. The Toronto Star, citing police, said he had been “horribly mutilated.” “It was a terrible sight,” a police spokesman said.

His full name was William Duncan Robinson. He was 24. He worked in the accounting department of a supermarket, and the Star later described him as an accountant with a grocery store chain.

Black and white photo of murder victim William Duncan Robinson
Murder victim William Duncan Robinson

Neighbours told the Star they last saw him leaving his apartment at 9:30 on Saturday night, November 25. Police believed he may have gone to “a homosexual bar in the Yonge and College Sts. area” and returned later with his killer.

Jennifer Singer lived in the apartment next door with her roommate, Erin Moore. They often heard Robinson’s stereo playing loud late at night. That Saturday they did not. Between 11 and 12:30, Singer told the Star, she heard “a strange hollow sound” from his apartment. She almost called police, then decided not to.

“I found it a bit spooky,” she said. “It was very quiet next door except for that strange sound.”

The Star later reported that Robinson was last seen at the St. Charles Tavern on Yonge St. at 1:30 a.m.

The Star’s report ran the next day under the headline “Homosexual killing 14th in 3½ years.” It opened: “Metro recorded another homosexual killing yesterday.” Police said it was the 14th “homosexual-related slaying” in Metro in three and a half years, out of 128 killings. Half of the 14 remained unsolved.

The paper described Robinson as “shy, well-dressed.” A neighbour, Tony Filippelli, said he had seen him “in several homosexual bars” since Robinson moved into the building a year earlier. Brant Savoy, who lived with Filippelli, described Robinson as “a quiet, shy man who didn’t seem to have many visitors.” The headline had already told readers what kind of killing it was. These details told them what kind of man.

Police composite sketch of murder suspect in William Robinson murder
Police composite sketch of murder suspect in William Robinson murder

“I hope they find the person who did it,” Savoy said. “We gays aren’t afraid of what happened in this building.” His was the only use of the word gay in the paper’s coverage.

The Star listed the other unsolved killings of gay men in the city. Fred Fontain, 33, a CBC technician, was beaten in the St. Charles Tavern in December 1975. James Taylor, 41, a painter and decorator, was beaten with a baseball bat in his North York apartment in February 1976. James Kennedy, 49, a federal income tax employee, was strangled with a towel in his Jarvis St. apartment in September 1976. Brian Latocki, 24, a bank financial analyst, was tortured and stabbed in his Erskine Ave. apartment in January 1977. Alex Leblanc, 29, a disco manager, was found dead in his St. Joseph St. apartment in September 1978. Harold Walkley, 51, a part-time University of Toronto lecturer, was stabbed in his Borden St. home.

On Saturday, December 2, the Star ran Robinson’s photograph under the caption “Robinson: No. 49.” His death was the 49th murder in Metro that year, the same number as at that point in 1977. Twelve were unsolved, a record. Insp. Norman Hobson, head of the homicide squad, said that in most cases the killers had not been well known by their victims. “The days of settling accounts by fisticuffs are over,” he said.

The investigators, Staff Sgt. Gerald Stevenson and Sgt. Robert McLean, had found no one who remembered or saw anything. The paper said they had “only one sketchy motive — a possible quarrel between homosexuals.” Hobson asked anyone with information, however small, to come forward.

The Star set Robinson’s case beside the year’s other unsolved killings. Among them was Alex (Sandy) LeBlanc, the disco manager, whom the paper described as “believed to be a homosexual.” He had been found mutilated and stabbed 100 times in the bedroom of his apartment. The paper attached no such hedge to Robinson.

The others on the list were Donald Rochester, a caretaker at the Toronto Lawn and Tennis Club, found shot in the head on February 13; Harold Fagan, 63, a CNE concessionaire, and his wife, Florence, 62, found shot in their Dewbourne Ave. home on March 6; John de Filippo, 31, shot on May 4 by two men posing as pizza deliverymen at his father-in-law’s home on Fallsport Cres.; Thomas Ikola, 68, beaten to death with a whisky bottle and found on August 19; David James Gardhouse, 34, of Mississauga, stabbed twice and found in a Lauder Ave. driveway on September 24; Bok Kan Lem, 33, kicked to death in a Bay and Dundas St. parkette on October 11; Walter Sanderson, 65, a watchman beaten to death with an iron bar on October 20; and Kenneth Cameron, 30, and Joseph Paul Landry, 36, whom the paper called “skid road” habitués, beaten to death in mid-November.

The next day, the Sunday Star’s week-in-review page said that if the case followed the others, police had “only a 50 per cent chance” of finding his killer. Part of the difficulty, it said, was police’s “lack of contacts in Toronto’s homosexual community.”

On December 9, Metro police asked the public for help and released a composite drawing of the man they believed was the last person to see Robinson alive. The two had been seen walking out of a Yonge St. tavern together at 2:30 a.m.

Police described the man as 27 to 30, between 6-foot-5 and 6-foot-7, with a lanky build. He had greasy brown hair past his ears, a scruffy goatee, sloping shoulders and dirty hands. He walked “in a clumsy manner” and had “extreme body odor.” In the tavern he had asked about buying drugs. He rolled his own cigarettes. He wore a maroon V-neck pullover with a white T-shirt, a bulky dark jacket, khaki work pants, tan work boots and a blue touque with a tassel.

The report repeated the police count: Robinson was the 14th gay man murdered in Metro in three and a half years.

On May 31, 1979, a $10,000 reward was posted for information. The Star reported that Robinson had been slashed severely and stabbed repeatedly by a man he met in the St. Charles Tavern. It called his death one of 11 unsolved murders in 1978. In December 1979 the reward was still outstanding, through the Metro Police Commission.

The record disagrees with itself. The papers called him Duncan Robinson, William Robinson and William (Duncan) Robinson. They gave his age as 24, and once as 28. The police file gives 25. The reported times of his last night do not line up.

No one has been charged. Toronto police list the case in their cold case files as Homicide #49/1978.

Vital statistics

FieldDetail
NameWilliam Duncan (Duncan) Robinson; also reported as William Robinson and William (Duncan) Robinson
Age24 (police cold case file: 25; one report: 28)
GenderMale
OccupationAccounting department, supermarket chain
Date of deathNovember 28, 1978
Manner of deathStabbing
Location205 Vaughan Road, Toronto

Sources

  • Toronto Star, November 29, 1978, p. A3
  • Toronto Star, December 2, 1978, p. A6
  • Sunday Star, December 3, 1978, p. A9
  • Toronto Star, December 9, 1978, p. A2
  • Toronto Star, June 1, 1979, p. A4
  • Toronto Star, December 15, 1979, p. A4
  • Toronto Police Service, Cold Case Files, Homicide #49/1978

 


Murder Village Map

 

 

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.