George Matthew “Peaches” Roach – Stabbed in Allan Gardens

At about 8:30 on the morning of Saturday, October 24, 1981, a woman walking home from work found a man’s body in Allan Gardens, the Toronto Star reported. The Toronto Sun reported that the man was fully clothed and lay on a raised flower bed outside the horticultural building. Police said it was easy to see from 50 yards away.

The dead man was George Matthew Roach, 46, of Edgewood Avenue. Police said he had been stabbed in the left side of the chest. Witnesses told the Sun he had also been hit in the face with considerable force and was badly bruised. A trail of blood ran along a stone path about 30 yards west of the body. A post mortem that night found that he died of a stab wound to the left lung. The weapon was not recovered. Investigators said robbery did not appear to be a motive.

Allan Gardens photo by James Victor Salmon
Allan Gardens photo by James Victor Salmon

The Sun reported an estimated time of death of about midnight. The Star reported that investigators speculated he was stabbed sometime after midnight near a park greenhouse and collapsed on a sidewalk near a flower garden. It was Metro Toronto’s 44th murder of 1981. At the same point in 1980 there had been 39.

The Sun described Roach as a single, unemployed laborer who lived in a small second-floor apartment. The Star called him an unemployed drifter. A neighbour, Monica Snowyer, told the Sun he was a loner who “took a few drinks.” Homicide detectives Staff Sgt. Wilson and Sgt. Joseph Cziraky searched the apartment and found nothing that pointed to a motive. Police believed, the Sun reported, that Roach had gone for an early morning walk and been accosted by an armed attacker.

Friends told the Sun that Roach was one of 10 children of Frank and Gertrude Roach. Frank, 84, was in the Fudger House rest home after a stroke. Gertrude and another son were dead. Roach’s brother Donald told the Sun the family was in “deep shock” and that it was “now a police matter.” He would not comment on a motive.

Leo Munn, 61, a regular in the park, told the Sun he did not know Roach but worried about walking there at night. “You never know when someone’s going to jump you,” he said. On Monday, October 26, homicide investigators questioned people who frequent the park around Sherbourne, Jarvis, Gerrard and Carlton Streets. Police said someone downtown probably had information that might help identify the killer.

A Star death notice said Roach died suddenly on October 24. Family services were to be held on Tuesday, October 27, at the St. James Cemetery and Crematorium chapel, with interment at St. John’s (Norway) Cemetery.

On Monday, November 9, Metro police charged two men with second-degree murder in Roach’s death: Lawrence Perrault, 22, of Dundas Street East, and R.B.S., a teenager. The Globe and Mail reported the arrests the next morning.

The Body Politic, a Toronto paper covering the gay community, said in its December issue that homicide investigators had solved the third murder of a gay man in the last three months. The same issue reported that on Monday, November 16, a roommate found John Henry Martin, 33, an unemployed hairdresser, stabbed to death in his apartment on Jarvis Street. The paper described him as a gay man known to be a frequent bar-goer.

The Body Politic reported that Kevin McBride, 47, an interior decorator, was found in his Sheppard Avenue East apartment on May 17, 1982, killed by repeated stab wounds to the upper torso. His killer took his credit cards and car. Police offered a $10,000 reward.

Perrault went on trial for second-degree murder before Mr. Justice A. W. Maloney and a jury in the Ontario Supreme Court. On Tuesday, June 22, Perrault, 23, testified that he was a prostitute and was soliciting in Allan Gardens, near Jarvis and Gerrard Streets, when Roach approached him and made no mention of money. He said he turned the approach down. Roach then grabbed his hair and ordered him to perform sexual acts, Perrault said. Roach threatened to kill him if he refused and pulled out a knife. Perrault said he grabbed the knife after Roach put it down, and began “jabbing” at him as Roach came toward him.

Under cross-examination Perrault could not explain why he had no bruises or scratches when Roach had a number of bruises. He said repeatedly that he “jabbed” at Roach’s stomach, but the autopsy found knife wounds only in Roach’s back, three of them, the Globe reported. Crown attorney Robert Ash told him it was “absolutely impossible” for it to have happened as he described. Ash also criticized him for not calling the police or an ambulance. Perrault said he was too scared to do anything.

The Crown’s case, the Globe reported, was that Perrault killed Roach after Roach refused to pay for sex. The Sun reported that when he was arrested Perrault told homicide officers he knifed Roach in the back when Roach did not pay the $20 they had agreed on. The Sun also reported that Perrault and a friend met Roach in Allan Gardens. The Globe reported that R.B.S. was to be tried separately at the request of Perrault’s lawyer, and that he had testified that he saw Perrault go through Roach’s pockets before running from the dying man. Perrault denied it.

On Thursday, June 24, the jury of eight men and four women rejected second-degree murder and found Perrault guilty of manslaughter. The Star’s headline called him a “male prostitute.” The Globe’s brief called him a “homosexual prostitute.” The Star said Roach was also known as Peaches. Maloney said it had been “an unpleasant and difficult case” and called the verdict “a reasonable one on the evidence.”

The Crown offered no evidence against R.B.S., who was 17, and he was cleared of the murder charge. “I hope you realize what a lucky young man you are,” Maloney told him. The Star said he burst into tears. He was held pending the outcome of other charges.

In July, The Body Politic reported, Dale Clarence Thompson and Lloyd Edward Wilson were found guilty of the murder of David Murphy, an artist, and sentenced to life. The trial heard that Murphy met them in Allan Gardens in the early hours of June 27, 1981, and with promises of money persuaded them to come home with him. When he refused to pay in the morning, they beat him with a hammer and strangled him with an electric cord.

Allan Gardens visitor Leo Munn points to police chalk marks where George Roach was stabbed. Photo by Gus Carlson, The Sun
Allan Gardens visitor Leo Munn points to police chalk marks where George Roach was stabbed. Photo by Gus Carlson, The Sun

On August 7, police found the body of Rawle Ramnanan, 35, in his Avenue Road apartment. The Body Politic reported that he was nude and had been tied up before being stabbed repeatedly in the chest and stomach. His apartment showed no signs of forced entry. On August 12 the Metro Toronto Police Commission announced a shake-up in the senior ranks of the homicide squad. The paper said it was apparently a response to public concern over unsolved murders, and reported in its September issue that police had made no arrest in the McBride or Ramnanan cases.

About three weeks before the sentencing hearing, Maloney was told that a juror wanted to testify for Perrault. He delayed sentencing to consider what he called, to the best of his knowledge, “unheard of.”

On Tuesday, October 19, Simone Gruenfelder, an elementary school teacher who had sat on the jury, testified on Perrault’s behalf. The Star said it was believed to be the first such development in Canada. The Globe reported that she had visited Perrault in jail at least once a week over the summer, and described him as a “native Indian” from Sault Ste. Marie. The Sun reported that she had written to him and received five replies signed “Sincerely, Larry” and, in one case, “Hugs and kisses, Larry.” She told the court she wanted to make him feel “not abandoned, not alone.”

Ash suggested her sympathy was misplaced, the Sun reported, and asked why she had not offered help to Roach’s family. The Star reported that she agreed she had shown no similar concern for them. “I cannot go and support everyone,” she said, explaining that Roach’s life was over and that Perrault “is still young and has a future.” The book Any Other Way: How Toronto Got Queer reports that a juror, an elementary school teacher, defended Perrault with the words “Just because he is a male prostitute doesn’t mean he can’t be raped.”

Perrault told Maloney he was sorry for what he had done and wanted a chance to prove himself. The judge sentenced him to eight years. He said he would have given him 10 but for the year Perrault had already spent in custody, the Globe reported. Maloney said he had “considerable compassion” for Perrault, who was orphaned as a teenager, but said the crime was an “unwarranted killing with some brutal elements,” the Sun reported.

The Sun quoted Maloney as saying Perrault was “out in the night soliciting strangers armed with a knife.” The Star quoted him as saying “you were out soliciting” for sex, which he described as unlawful activity that could foreseeably be dangerous. Both papers quoted his words “despicable, deplorable conduct,” and the Sun reported that he said other young people must know they would be severely dealt with if they killed someone in the course of it. Maloney also told Perrault he was “fortunate”: under a recent Supreme Court of Canada decision, a jury at a trial held then would have been told to acquit him or convict him of second-degree murder, not manslaughter, the Globe reported.

Murderer Larry Perrault
Murderer Larry Perrault

The Sun described Roach as “a bachelor also known as Peaches because he used to pick up young men.” The Star called him “a homosexual known as Peaches.” The Globe said Perrault knifed him “during a sordid, late-night encounter.”

Defence counsel Michael DeRubeis, who had asked for a sentence of two years less a day, called the eight years “harsh and excessive” and said he would appeal. The Globe’s court report for April 2, 1984, recorded that the Court of Appeal granted Perrault leave to appeal his sentence and dismissed the appeal.

Vital statistics

FieldDetail
NameGeorge Matthew “Peaches” Roach (some 1981 reports spelled his middle name “Mathew”)
Age46
GenderMale
OccupationLaborer (the Sun described him as single and unemployed)
Date of deathOctober 24, 1981 (found about 8:30 a.m.; the Sun estimated the time of death at about midnight)
Manner of deathStabbed
LocationAllan Gardens, near the horticultural building, 19 Horticultural Ave.
AccusedLawrence Raymond (Larry) Perrault, 22 or 23; R.B.S., 17 when cleared
ChargeSecond-degree murder (both accused)
Defence counselMichael DeRubeis (for Perrault)
Crown counselRobert Ash
JudgeMr. Justice A. W. Maloney
VerdictPerrault: manslaughter, June 24, 1982 (the 1984 appeal list gives June 25). R.B.S.: acquitted after the Crown offered no evidence
SentencePerrault: eight years, October 19, 1982

Sources

  • Toronto Sun, October 25, 1981, p. 22
  • Toronto Star, October 25, 1981, p. A3
  • Toronto Sun, October 26, 1981, p. 2
  • Toronto Sun, October 27, 1981, p. 21
  • Toronto Star, October 27, 1981, p. D20
  • The Globe and Mail, November 10, 1981, p. 4
  • The Body Politic, no. 79, December 1981, p. 10
  • The Globe and Mail, June 23, 1982, p. 4
  • The Globe and Mail, June 25, 1982, p. 12
  • Toronto Star, June 25, 1982, p. A9
  • The Body Politic, September 1982, p. 14
  • The Globe and Mail, October 20, 1982, p. 5
  • Toronto Star, October 20, 1982, p. A6
  • Toronto Sun, October 20, 1982, p. 24
  • The Globe and Mail, April 2, 1984, p. B4
  • John Lorinc, Tim McCaskell, Maureen Fitzgerald, Jane Farrow and Stephanie Chambers, eds., Any Other Way: How Toronto Got Queer
  • Photographs: Allan Gardens, James Victor Salmon

Murder Village Map

 

 

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.