At about 9 p.m. on Saturday, April 14, 1990, Michael Boley did not arrive at the suite of Irene Kalantarow for his regular visit. She was an elderly, handicapped resident of the 30-storey condominium on Homewood Avenue, north of Carlton Street. Boley, a fellow resident, had cared for her over many years. She got the building superintendent to open his door.
The Toronto Star reported that Kalantarow was still at the door of Boley’s apartment, distressed, when a neighbour, Dave Middleton, came home to find the superintendent waiting for police. The superintendent told him there had been a tragedy on the 27th floor. Middleton, who had known Boley since 1972, went in. He told the Star that Boley was lying on his back, fully clothed, tied by the ankles and wrists, each to a corner of the bed. Bedclothes lay over the body, and only the top of his head showed.
Boley was 56 and a Revenue Canada tax auditor. Kalantarow told the Star he was “the kindest and nicest person in the world.”

Police did not at first call it a murder. On Monday, April 16, the Star reported that homicide detectives were treating it as a “suspicious death” and that an autopsy had not determined the cause. A police spokesperson said it appeared to have been “death by natural causes at this time,” but that police saw it as happening under suspicious circumstances. The building had extremely tight security, and there were no visible signs of a struggle. Investigators suspected that whoever was with Boley had been invited in.
On Wednesday, April 18, the Star reported that homicide detectives had arrested a suspect at College Park provincial court. Rodney William Glode, 24, of no fixed address, was appearing on robbery and forcible confinement charges when Detective Sergeants Mike Davis and Mike Pinfold arrested him again, this time for second-degree murder. He had been questioned about Boley’s death earlier. Police believed robbery was the motive. They would not say what evidence showed it was a murder, what had been taken, or how they had found their suspect. The Star noted that the building’s cameras recorded everyone who entered and left, and that it was Metro Toronto’s 17th homicide of the year, compared with 13 at the same point in 1989.
On Wednesday, May 15, 1991, Glode appeared before Mr. Justice John O’Driscoll of the Ontario Court’s General Division and pleaded guilty to second-degree murder. The hearing that day set out what the Crown said he had done over the previous spring.
Assistant Crown attorneys Sandy Kingston and Sonia Brander told the court that between March 18 and April 14, 1990, Glode got into the homes of seven men by promising sexual favours. The Globe and Mail reported that the first victim was a bartender at a west-end club who invited Glode there for after-hours drinks on March 18. He was struck over the head, then bound and gagged. He spent six weeks in hospital with severe head injuries and was left with permanent balance problems. Five more robberies followed, on March 20, March 25, April 6, April 8 and April 12. In each, Glode was picked up by a man who offered money for sex. In most cases the victim agreed to have his hands tied and then found himself gagged and bound hand and foot. The Star reported that Glode used belts and scarves, threatened the men with knives and took whatever he could. The court was told each victim suffered serious and permanent injuries. At the first scene Glode left a fingerprint, but it was not matched to one taken seven years earlier, when he was charged with assaulting his landlord.
Boley was the seventh. Kingston told the court that he died of asphyxia when the shirt, belt and tie used to gag him blocked his air passages. The Globe reported that the autopsy found he had been gagged with cloths covering his nose as well as his mouth. The Toronto Sun reported that his hands and feet were tied so tightly they were purple, with a tie stuffed in his mouth and a shirt tied around it. His apartment had been ransacked, and a knife lay on the living room floor.
Glode was first arrested on April 15, 1990, the day after the killing, according to the Globe, for failing to pay a cab fare. The Star reported Kingston as saying he was wearing Boley’s shoes and had the keys to Boley’s condominium in his pocket. In jail he talked to an undercover officer. Kingston said he bragged about his success at being picked up by gay men: “I guess I’ve got a pretty face the faggots like.” The Globe quoted him on Boley: he had “robbed a faggot and he died. It was my luck he had a bad heart.” The Sun worded the remark differently. It had Glode telling the officer he “robbed a fag with a bad heart” and “wouldn’t have choked him so hard” had he known. He also said he had meant to go back to Boley’s place to steal more, but the police had arrived by the time he got there.
Kingston asked that Glode wait 18 or 19 years before parole eligibility. She described him as a very dangerous person “who must be removed from society for a very long time.” His lawyer, Charles Ryall of Niagara Falls, proposed 14 years. Ryall said Glode had spared the system two long jury trials by pleading guilty and had a prior record of only “nickel-and-dime” offences. The judge was given little about Glode’s life beyond the fact that he was born in Newfoundland, had a Grade 11 education and had seldom worked since coming to Toronto as a teenager. Outside the courtroom, a homicide squad officer who worked the case called Glode “a one-man wrecking crew in the homosexual community.”
The coverage of the hearing put Boley’s sexuality in the headlines. The Sun’s headline on May 16 read “‘Brutal’ killer hunted gays,” and its report, relaying Kingston’s account, called Boley “a known homosexual.” The Star’s headline that day was “Male prostitute to get life for murder.” The Globe’s sentencing report described Glode as a drifter who “posed as a male prostitute to rob homosexuals.” The two Star reports from April 1990 had not mentioned Boley’s sexuality. They called his death “bizarre” and described a fully clothed man tied to his bed.
Glode was sentenced on Friday, May 17. The Globe reported that the judge made no effort to hide his frustration at how little he had been told about Glode’s past or about what had caused the four-week rampage. He offered to adjourn for psychological reports, in fairness to Glode and to the people who would “look after him for the next decade at least.” Ryall said Glode had already had “a battery of tests” and would get any treatment he needed in prison. Asked if he had anything to say, Glode said he was sorry and “I didn’t mean to hurt anyone.”
O’Driscoll said he had to accept the Crown’s view “that you are an extremely dangerous 25-year-old man.” The Sun reported that he told Glode he had shown a “vicious and callous attitude for human life” and that his targeting of gay men made it “apparent you think these people are fair game.” He gave Glode the mandatory life sentence for second-degree murder and raised the period before parole eligibility from 10 years to 17. He also imposed concurrent 10-year terms on the robbery counts and a lifetime ban on possessing firearms or ammunition. The Sun’s headline was “Stalked gays, killer given life sentence.” The Star’s was “Life term for killer who preyed on gays.” The Globe’s read “Man sentenced to life in murder of homosexual.”
The papers disagree on the number of robbery counts. The Globe reported a plea to six counts on May 16 and sentences on four counts on May 18. The Sun reported four. The Star reported three, both times. The Globe and Star name the prosecutor as Sandy Kingston, the Sun as Sandra Kingston.
Vital statistics
| Field | Detail |
|---|---|
| Name | Michael Boley |
| Age | 56 |
| Gender | Male |
| Occupation | Revenue Canada tax auditor |
| Date of death | April 14, 1990 (body found that evening) |
| Manner of death | Asphyxiation |
| Location | 40 Homewood Avenue, Toronto |
| Accused | Rodney William Glode, 24 at arrest, 25 at sentencing |
| Charge | Second-degree murder |
| Defence counsel | Charles Ryall |
| Crown counsel | Sandy Kingston (Sandra in the Sun) and Sonia Brander |
| Judge | Mr. Justice John O’Driscoll |
| Verdict | Guilty plea to second-degree murder, May 15, 1991 |
| Sentence | Life, no parole eligibility for 17 years, May 17, 1991; concurrent 10-year terms on robbery counts (three or four, depending on the paper) |
Sources
- The Toronto Star, April 16, 1990, p. A3
- The Toronto Star, April 18, 1990, p. A32
- The Globe and Mail, May 16, 1991, p. A12
- The Toronto Star, May 16, 1991, p. C28
- The Toronto Sun, May 16, 1991, p. 30
- The Globe and Mail, May 18, 1991, p. A8
- The Toronto Star, May 18, 1991, p. A18
- The Toronto Sun, May 18, 1991, p. 4
Murder Village Map
WAYNE THROWER
Mike and I lived in the same building, 40 Homewood Ave. We often joked about the neighborhood. Michael Boley, was one of the nicest people I ever met: kind, generous, and helpful. Mike had a great sense of humor and he was a good friend, I knew he was gay but it never effected our friendship, I am sorry to hear of his passing and I would have done just about anything to protect Michael, God Rest His Soul. I had moved out of the building by 1990, Mike was a true loss.
Wayne Thrower