Henry Durost – Psychiatrist Murdered

Police Constable Glen Wilson was the first officer into the 17th-floor apartment on Jackes Avenue, near Yonge Street and St. Clair Avenue East, on Tuesday, January 6, 2004. He described what he found to the jury at a murder trial in February 2006, the Toronto Star reported. A 78-year-old man lay face down on the living room floor. There was blood around his head, in his hair and on his shirt. His left rear pants pocket was pulled out. His arms were behind him, in the small of his back. The skin on his left forearm, visible because the sleeve was pulled up, looked “discoloured and indented.” Wilson said there was no evidence that the lock on the door had been tampered with or pried open.

The man was Dr. Henry Durost, a psychiatrist. The Star reported that he had been medical director of the Queen Street Mental Health Centre from 1971 to 1981 and clinical director of the Clarke Institute of Psychiatry from 1981 to 1990. He was retired but on the honorary medical staff of the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, and he still saw patients. His colleagues there had become worried when he did not come to work. At the trial, the court heard that a co-worker contacted the building’s manager to check on him. The Star reported that police received a call at about 2:30 p.m.

His death was the city’s first homicide of 2004, the Globe and Mail reported. Toronto had 65 homicides in 2003, up from 62 the year before.

Black and white photo of murder victim Henry Durost
Murder victim Henry Durost

At a press conference on Wednesday, January 7, Detective Sergeant Alan Comeau of the homicide squad said Durost had been strangled and showed other signs of trauma. Police said he was last seen in his building at about 6 p.m. on Saturday, January 3, and was killed between that night and Monday morning. They said the apartment had been robbed but would not say what was missing. They said there were no signs of forced entry. The building had security staff at the door each day and an “extensive” video system, which police were reviewing, the Globe and Mail reported.

Dr. Vivian Rakoff, a former director of the Clarke Institute who had known Durost since they were students in England in the 1950s, told the Star that Durost had been at a New Year’s Day party at his home and “he was fine.” He described Durost as “a shy man” and said, “He was gentle.” Durost’s death notice in the Globe and Mail listed a Requiem Eucharist at the Cathedral Church of St. James on Monday, January 12.

The coverage turned quickly to Durost’s sexuality. The Globe and Mail reported that police “revealed” Durost was gay and were investigating whether he was targeted because of it. Its headline read “Strangled gay psychiatrist likely targeted by killer, police believe.” Comeau said investigators were looking at Durost’s computer activities and at the possibility that he went to gay strip bars. “The homicide squad investigators believe Dr. Durost was specifically targeted,” he said. The Star’s headline read “Probe to include patrons at city’s gay strip bars.” It reported that the investigation would focus on patrons of gay strip bars Durost was “rumoured to have visited” and on “any possible Internet connections he might have made.” Comeau told reporters it was too early to tell whether Durost’s sexual orientation was “a big factor.”

Comeau said investigators would look for links to other homicides. The Star noted that police were still searching for the killer of David Buller, a 50-year-old University of Toronto art lecturer stabbed to death three years earlier in his office in the Connaught Building. That investigation, the Star said, had drawn police into gay chat lines Buller frequented.

On Wednesday, January 14, Toronto police identified a suspect from forensic evidence found in Durost’s apartment and told York Regional Police, who were already investigating the man for allegedly assaulting and threatening his parents in Vaughan two days earlier. A York Regional Police spokesman said a fight had broken out that Monday morning over allegations that the man had taken money from his sister. Investigators went looking in places the man was believed to frequent. At about 10 p.m., he was spotted carrying a duffel bag at a strip mall on Finch Avenue West. He was arrested moments later in a nearby coffee shop, the Star reported. The Globe and Mail called it a doughnut shop. He no longer had the bag. He was carrying a screwdriver and a pair of vice-grips, police said. Police later found a duffel bag in a dumpster and said it held evidence related to the killing.

The man was Joseph Giuseppe Carnovale, 38, of no fixed address. He was charged with first-degree murder, two counts of assault, threatening death and possession of burglar tools. Police described him as an unemployed drug addict. The Globe and Mail’s headline called him a “drifter.” Its report described Durost as “a gay man who lived alone in a high-rise apartment in an affluent neighbourhood.” Carnovale appeared in a College Park courtroom on January 15 and was remanded in custody for a bail hearing.

Photo of police entering the building where Henry Durost was murdered
Police entering the building where Henry Durost was murdered

At a press conference that day, Comeau said the prime motive still appeared to be robbery. Police put the value of the missing property at between $2,000 and $3,000, the Star reported, and were checking pawn shops in Toronto and elsewhere in the province. Comeau would not say what the forensic evidence was, only that it had been “critical” in identifying the suspect quickly. He said police were still trying to establish how Carnovale and Durost knew each other and that Durost “may very well have known the accused.” Police planned to look through Durost’s patient files to see whether Carnovale had been a patient.

On January 21, Xtra reported that Comeau had told it police did not release information about Durost’s social or sexual life. It said the Globe and Mail and the Star, citing friends and neighbours, had reported that Durost frequented a gay strip bar and suggested he might have met his killer there or on the Internet. Howard Shulman of the 519 Community Centre’s Anti-violence Program told Xtra it was typical of police and the media to treat the murder of queer people differently. “They seem to see us as being totally driven by sex,” he said.

In April 2005, the Star reported that Carnovale had been committed to stand trial for first-degree murder. On Friday, February 10, 2006, he offered to plead guilty to manslaughter. The Crown refused, and Justice Susanne Goodman of the Ontario Superior Court entered a plea of not guilty to first-degree murder. The trial opened on Monday, February 13.

Deputy Crown Attorney Ann Morgan told the jury that Carnovale went to Durost’s home “to take financial advantage of the doctor” and left with “the spoils of his plan.” She said Dr. Michael Pollanen, Ontario’s chief forensic pathologist, would testify that Durost died of strangulation and also suffered broken ribs, blunt force trauma to the head, injuries to the wrists and hands, and sharp force injuries to the ear and neck. She said Durost was killed between 10 p.m. on January 3 and the next morning. His housekeeper, who last saw him on January 2, was expected to testify that money, jewellery, two knives and a fork were missing, and that bleach and other cleaning products had been used in a home where Durost never cleaned. Despite the cleaning, Morgan said, Carnovale “left his calling card,” his DNA. His blood was found inside a kitchen drawer where the forks and knives were kept and inside the left side of the fridge.

Sobia Malik, a forensic biologist at the Centre of Forensic Sciences, testified that Carnovale’s DNA was under fingernail clippings taken from Durost. Under cross-examination by defence lawyer Steven Fishbayn, she agreed the DNA could have ended up there through consensual sexual activity.

On Monday, March 6, Carnovale, 40, testified in his own defence. Earlier that day, Fishbayn had shown the jury three of the 29 adult videos found in Durost’s apartment. The three he showed included gay bondage themes. The Star reported that Carnovale described how he beat, stabbed and strangled Durost but could not say why. “I took a man’s life and I couldn’t take it back,” he said.

Carnovale said he and Durost had consensual sex at least seven times over more than a year, including on the night of the killing. Durost always gave him money afterward, once as much as $400, he said. He admitted that he supported a cocaine and heroin habit of $600 to $1,000 a day mainly by break and enters. He denied going to Durost’s apartment to rob him.

He said he knocked on Durost’s door at about 11 p.m. on Saturday, January 3, in the middle of a crack cocaine binge, after several days without eating or sleeping. He wanted money and a warm place to stay. They had drinks, and he smoked crack he had brought with him. They began having sex on the couch, including bindings. Carnovale said the marks on Durost’s wrists came from the terrycloth he used to tie Durost up as sex play. Of sex like that, he said, “part of the fun is struggling to get out.” He said he ran low on crack and wanted to leave to get more. He promised to come back, but Durost begged him to stay and grabbed his arm. Carnovale said he hit Durost with a ceramic pot. Asked why, he said, “All I wanted was more crack. I just lost it, I don’t know.” He said he then hit Durost once or twice with a vase, punched him a few times in the temple, got on top of him and began choking him. He also took a knife from the kitchen and stabbed Durost once in the collarbone area. Asked whether he was trying to kill Durost, he said no.

The Crown’s case for first-degree murder rested on the claim that Carnovale killed Durost while forcibly confining him by tying his hands behind his back, the Court of Appeal later wrote. No restraints or ligatures were found on Durost’s wrists. Pollanen testified that the wrist injuries suggested binding at around the time of death and could have been caused up to four hours earlier.

In his closing address, Fishbayn told the jury that Carnovale was not trying to avoid responsibility for “the senseless act he has committed.” He argued that Carnovale was so affected by cocaine, alcohol, lack of sleep, lack of food and his emotional state that he could not form the intent to kill. Morgan told jurors the trial was not about whether Carnovale used cocaine. She said he had used crack for more than 20 years and was very tolerant of it. He cleaned up the scene and left with bags of evidence and goods he could sell, she said, which showed he knew what he was doing. The jury heard that Carnovale had a string of theft and drug convictions. It did not hear that he also had three convictions for assault and one for threatening death, the Star reported.

On Friday, March 17, the jury found Carnovale guilty of first-degree murder. It rejected his claim that he was too high on cocaine to realize he was killing Durost, whom the Star called his “sometime lover.” Justice Goodman sentenced him to life in prison with no chance of parole for 25 years, the mandatory minimum. “He was a pillar of the community,” said homicide Det. Wayne Banks. Durost’s great-nephew, Greg Mann, 29, said it was the best possible result. The family’s concern, he said, was “simply to ensure that Mr. Carnovale could not hurt anyone else.”

Carnovale appealed, asking the Ontario Court of Appeal to replace the first-degree murder conviction with one for second-degree murder. The court dismissed the appeal on October 28, 2010. In its summary of the facts, it said Durost had befriended Carnovale and from time to time given him temporary refuge and money in exchange for consensual sexual activities.

Vital statistics

FieldDetail
NameDr. Henry Durost (Henry B. Durost in his death notices)
Age78
GenderMale
OccupationPsychiatrist; former medical director, Queen Street Mental Health Centre
Date of deathJanuary 3 or 4, 2004 (body found January 6; death notices gave January 6)
Manner of deathStrangulation, with blunt force and sharp force injuries
Location7 Jackes Avenue, 17th-floor apartment, near Yonge Street and St. Clair Avenue East
AccusedJoseph Giuseppe Carnovale, 38 (also reported as 33 and 36)
ChargeFirst-degree murder
Defence counselSteven Fishbayn
Crown counselAnn Morgan
JudgeJustice Susanne Goodman
VerdictFirst-degree murder, March 17, 2006
SentenceLife in prison, no parole eligibility for 25 years

Sources

  • The Globe and Mail, January 7, 2004, pp. A1, A9
  • Toronto Star, January 7, 2004, pp. B1, B5
  • The Globe and Mail, January 8, 2004, p. A14
  • Toronto Star, January 8, 2004, pp. B1, B4
  • The Globe and Mail, January 9, 2004, p. S5 (death notices); January 10, 2004, p. S6 (death notices)
  • Toronto Star, January 9, 2004, p. F6 (death notices)
  • The Globe and Mail, January 15, 2004, p. A15
  • Toronto Star, January 15, 2004, p. B2
  • The Globe and Mail, January 16, 2004, p. A12
  • Toronto Star, January 16, 2004, p. F5
  • Xtra, “Arrest in Durost murder,” January 21, 2004
  • Toronto Star, April 29, 2005, p. F2
  • Toronto Star, February 14, 2006, p. B4
  • Toronto Star, March 7, 2006, p. B3
  • Toronto Star, March 18, 2006, p. A7
  • R. v. Carnovale, 2010 ONCA 716, Ontario Court of Appeal, October 28, 2010

 


Murder Village Map

 

 

1 thought on “Henry Durost – Psychiatrist Murdered”

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.