Darryl Lyle Turner – One Night, Three Murders

When

At about midnight on Monday, May 3, 1982, Ottawa police stopped a car that had run a caution light in the downtown. Staff-Inspector George Zhukow told the Globe and Mail that the two men inside produced an ownership document. The officers became suspicious of the ownership and of certain contents in the car, he said. The Toronto Star reported that the driver could not account for having the car, or for a stereo and some household goods in the back seat.

The men were held through the early hours of Tuesday, May 4. Ottawa police contacted Metro Toronto police. A check showed the car belonged to Darryl Lyle Turner of 18 Virginia Avenue in East York. Two Metro officers went to the house and got no answer at the door. At about 8 a.m. they forced their way in through a side door.

Inside were three dead men. The Globe reported one body on a bedroom floor and two in the basement. The Star reported that Joseph Eli Isaac had been stabbed in a main-floor bedroom. The men were partly clothed. Staff-Sgt. Jack Press said there was no sign of a struggle and that the men had probably died on Monday. Staff-Sgt. Arnold Mountford told the Star that “things were a bit of a mess,” which suggested either a fight or a ransacking.

Photo by Erik Christensen Globe and Mail
Photo by Erik Christensen Globe and Mail

The dead were Turner, 45 (the Globe spelled his first name Daryle); Isaac, 44; and Charles Roy Tanti, 27. An autopsy found that Turner and Tanti had been suffocated and Isaac stabbed. Police said Tanti’s neck also bore marks that seemed to show he had been strangled as well.

Turner was a native of Vancouver. He had rented the house since March 1970, according to his landlady, Christina Reiter, and sublet rooms to help meet the $475 monthly rent. She told the Star he paid on time and “took wonderful care of the house.” Since 1977 he had worked for Sterisystems Ltd. of Rexdale, a company that rents television sets to hospital patients. His most recent posting was Sunnybrook Hospital, the company’s general manager, Douglas Last, told the Globe. Turner had a sister in Vancouver whom he visited often.

Isaac and Tanti were roomers. Isaac had worked eight years as a laborer at Metro’s landfill site on Beare Road in Scarborough. He did not report for work at 7:30 a.m. on Monday, the Star said. His foreman, John Burden, said Isaac normally had a good record and was seldom late or absent without a reason. Tanti, originally from the Brampton area, was unemployed and on a medical disability pension, the Globe reported.

The May coverage turned quickly to the visitors. A Star photo caption told readers that neighbours had reported a constant stream of male visitors at the house. Joe Gulyas, 33, a mechanic and Canada Post shiftworker who lived across the street, told the Globe the men were nighthawks like him. He recalled cabs pulling up at all hours. He said he had thought the household was “bootlegging, or dealing in dope, or something.” He told the Star the men never made any noise or trouble. Peter Polito, 27, who lived next door, told the Star there were “so many guys in and out” that it was hard to keep track of them.

Barbara Litzinger, a neighbour on Cosburn Avenue, told the Globe the men were pleasant and talkative, that they kept a vegetable garden every year, and that the same three or four men had lived there for many years, “but lately there were many different men coming and going.” Al Sheffield, who owned a Cosburn Avenue grocery, said the men were polite. He said he sometimes saw them with “the odd, young hippie type.” Debbie Noseworthy, 26, who ran a nearby grocery, said one of the men told jokes and could be very witty. She had seen him on Sunday. A small white dog was always with one or the other of them.

Police told the Star they believed robbery was the motive. The autopsy, they said, produced no evidence to support conjecture that the killings were sex crimes. United Press International reported that the three deaths brought the number of murders in Toronto for the year to 18.

Courville was arrested in Ottawa. Joseph Norbert Courville, 25, of no fixed address, was charged on Tuesday with three counts of first-degree murder. Police said he had been living in Toronto. The second man stopped in Ottawa was interviewed and released. Metro detectives flew to Ottawa to question the men. Courville was brought to Toronto on Wednesday, May 5, and was scheduled to appear in College Park provincial court on Thursday at 10 a.m. His lawyer was Stanley Goldberg.

The Body Politic headed its June item “Triple-killing suspect nabbed at stop light” and described the murders of “three Toronto gay men.” It reported that homicide investigators found the house extensively ransacked and speculated that robbery was a motive.

On Friday, September 17, Courville pleaded guilty in Ontario Supreme Court to three counts of second-degree murder. The Star called him a 26-year-old drifter. Metro police Sgt. John Barbour testified to what Courville said after his arrest. Ottawa police had stopped the car, Barbour said, because it ran a red light. It carried papers belonging to Turner, and officers suspected it was stolen. When Courville was put in the back of a police car, he blurted out, “I’m a murderer.”

Turner murderer Joseph Courville by Tony Bock 1982
Turner murderer Joseph Courville by Tony Bock 1982

Courville told the officers he had been sitting in a bar when he was “approached by this guy.” He went back to Turner’s home to get money, he said, and added, “Faggots, they help you if you ask them.” United Press International reported that the two met in a downtown gay bar. Courville told police he did not know why he killed the three men, but that he hated homosexuals and that “everything went crazy” after Turner made advances. When Turner made a pass, the Star reported, Courville attacked him, tied him up and grabbed Tanti. Isaac “came at me and I stabbed him,” Courville said. After his arrest, a crying Courville said he did not even know the men’s names. “I’m a loony,” he said.

The Crown described how the two men had been bound. Turner and Tanti were found with their wrists and ankles tied to their necks, so that the more they struggled the tighter the ropes became. “Their very efforts to release themselves caused their deaths,” the prosecutor told the court. Isaac had been stabbed nine times in the chest.

Barbour testified that Isaac and Tanti were not homosexuals. The Star opened its report by saying Courville killed three people “after one of them made a homosexual advance.” The only account of that advance was Courville’s own statement to police. His lawyer, Earl Levy, told the court that Courville had twice been the victim of homosexual attacks, once at six or seven years old and once in a home for runaway boys. Levy also noted his history of drug and alcohol abuse, and a criminal record dating to 1973, United Press International reported.

Chief Justice Gregory Evans sentenced Courville to life in prison and ordered that he serve at least 15 years before parole eligibility, five more than the minimum, the Star reported. Evans called the killings “totally unnecessary and completely senseless.” He said Courville could have handled the three men without resorting to murder. It was not the worst case Ontario courts had seen, he said, but it was “certainly getting up in that range.”

The Globe and Mail reported the sentence in a short item on page 5, headed “Murdered 3, man gets 15 years.” It described three concurrent 15-year terms for second-degree murder, with no parole for 15 years. The Star, The Body Politic and United Press International each reported a life sentence.

Vital statistics

FieldDetail
NameDarryl Lyle Turner (spelled Daryle in the Globe and Mail)
BornVancouver; the Globe and Mail reported he would have turned 46 on May 4, 1982
Age45 (Globe and Mail); 46 (Toronto Star)
GenderMale
OccupationTelevision rental representative, Sterisystems Ltd.
Date of deathMay 3, 1982 (Monday, per police); one United Press International report gave May 1
Manner of deathSuffocation; wrists and ankles bound to his neck
Location18 Virginia Avenue, East York
AccusedJoseph Norbert Perceval Courville (Norbert Joseph Courville in United Press International), 25, 26 or 27 depending on the report
ChargeThree counts of first-degree murder; pleaded guilty to three counts of second-degree murder
Defence counselStanley Goldberg (first court appearance); Earl Levy (sentencing)
JudgeChief Justice Gregory Evans, Ontario Supreme Court
VerdictGuilty plea
SentenceLife, no parole eligibility for 15 years, September 17, 1982 (the Globe and Mail reported three concurrent 15-year terms)

Sources

  • The Globe and Mail, May 5, 1982, p. 5
  • The Globe and Mail, May 6, 1982, p. 5
  • Toronto Star, May 5, 1982, p. A13
  • Toronto Star, May 6, 1982, Metro page
  • The Globe and Mail, September 18, 1982, p. 5
  • Toronto Star, September 18, 1982, p. A19
  • The Body Politic, no. 84, June 1982, p. 14
  • The Body Politic, November 1982, p. 15
  • United Press International, May 5, 1982; September 17, 1982; September 18, 1982
  • Photographs: Jim Wilkes, Toronto Star; Erik Christensen, The Globe and Mail

Murder Village Map

 

 

2 thoughts on “Darryl Lyle Turner – One Night, Three Murders”

  1. Canadian law boggles my mind this guy murdered three! 3 innocent people for no damn reason, but he’s let out of prison?? I honestly think if a violent offender is let out of prison and commits another act of violence the people or person who made the decision to let them out should be held accountable. An accident is an accident. Killing three people is no fucking accident. R.I.P to the men who were murdered so brutally.

  2. I think Charles Tanti is a man I’ve been looking for, and if it’s him, he was gay. In 1981, my mom was diagnosed with cancer, and had to have surgery. I was 13, and Charlie, a friend of my mom’s, came to stay with me. I was NOT easy on him, poor guy. I’d met him before, and he stayed with us several times over the next year, so I knew him pretty well. In 1982, my mom found out our Charlie had been murdered–tied to a chair and tortured, Mom said. I’m ashamed that despite his regular presence in my life during that year, that I never cared to get to know him or even to try to like him. I don’t even know how my mom knew him or why she had him stay with us. She asked me to be better to him, because he had a hard life and was lonely.

    I’m trying to find our Charlie, and the only death that seems to fit the time frame and the little I know, seems to be the Charles Roy Tanti mentioned in this article. So far, I’ve been unable to discover any more info than this.

    If anyone knows more, could you please email me at heyalioop(at)gmail(dot)com? I’d sure appreciate it.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.