John Henry Martin – Jarvis Street Stabbing

Early on Monday, November 16, 1981, a man came home to the sixth-floor apartment he shared at 550 Jarvis Street. His roommate, John Henry Martin, was on a blood-soaked couch with stab wounds to the chest and face, the Toronto Star reported. The roommate, Ross Ball, 33, had been away for the weekend. A knife believed to be the murder weapon was in the apartment. The building stood a block from police headquarters, the Star said.

Martin was 33 and an unemployed hairdresser. He was last seen on Sunday, November 15, at about 10:30 p.m. The Star placed him in the dining lounge of the Selby Hotel on Sherbourne Street. The Body Politic reported that he left Boots, the bar at the Selby, with another man. Detectives told the Star they understood he had “befriended a man” while his “male roommate” was away. They suspected he had left the hotel with his killer.

Martin’s was the second killing in Metro that weekend. On Sunday, police found cab driver Peter Gamoulakos, 37, strangled in his parked cab near Eglinton Avenue West and Dufferin Street. They believed he died Saturday morning. The Star’s front page said Metro police were hunting two killers. It counted Martin as the seventh murder of the month, a record for November, and the 51st of the year. At the same point the year before, the count was 39. The record for a full year was 55, set in 1977.

Three weeks earlier, on October 24, George Matthew Roach had been stabbed to death in Allan Gardens. Two men were charged with second-degree murder on November 9. The Body Politic’s December issue carried the police appeal in Martin’s case. It described the Roach arrests as success in solving the third murder of a gay man within three months.

The Selby Hotel where John Martin met his killer
The Selby Hotel where John Martin met his killer

The paper printed the police description of Martin: white, 5 feet 6 inches, 134 pounds, with brown hair and a moustache. Police said he was known to be “a frequent bar-goer.” They asked anyone with information about his movements on Sunday and Monday to call the Homicide Squad.

Detectives had few leads. Staff Sgt. Robert Strathdee told The Body Politic that homicide had interviewed a number of people and received several anonymous tips, and that none led anywhere. He said detectives were having problems with “gay people who just won’t come forward.”

On December 3, the Star ran a count of the year’s killings: 54 confirmed, five with no charges laid. It listed one case among the baffling ones as “unemployed hairdresser John Henry Miller, 33,” stabbed in his sixth-floor Isabella Street apartment on the same weekend as the cab driver’s death. It added: “Police believe Miller was a homosexual.” The Star’s November reports had named him John Henry Martin, of Jarvis Street.

On Friday, January 22, 1982, two officers from 52 Division arrested Edward Michael Holness in a Yonge Street hotel, the Star reported. Holness, 23, was unemployed and of no fixed address. He was charged with first-degree murder and was to appear in Old City Hall court the next day. On March 18, the Star reported that police had arrested a second man, Gary Michael Hilton, 22, also of no fixed address. He too was charged with first-degree murder.

In July 1982, the Globe and Mail reported on a County Court trial of Alfred Peter Siegel. Siegel was charged with obstructing justice by trying to dissuade John Marshall from testifying at the murder trial of Hilton and Holness.

That trial opened before an Ontario Supreme Court jury on Tuesday, November 9, 1982. Hilton, 23, and Holness, 24, were charged with first-degree murder. The Star’s headline read “Homosexual stabbed over debt, trial told.”

Crown prosecutor Glen Orr told the jury the evidence would show both men were involved. The broken knife lay on the floor of Martin’s apartment, Orr said, and a pathologist found pieces of the blade in Martin’s head. A male prostitute had provided sexual services to Martin and was not paid, Orr said. The prostitute complained he had been “ripped off” by a trick. He pointed Martin out to Holness, who said, “Maybe I should kill the goof.” After Martin’s death was discovered, Holness was heard to say he “had taken care of the man.” Hilton was seen wearing another man’s pants after the killing. He said his own were being washed.

The Court of Appeal later described the evidence in similar terms. Both Holness and Hilton were male prostitutes, it said, and Martin was a customer of male prostitutes. Evidence was led that Martin had “ripped off” one of them by refusing to pay. Days before the killing, the court said, the rip-off was made known to Holness, and Martin was pointed out to him. The court’s account of Holness’s words afterward differed from the Star’s. He told an acquaintance there was no need to worry about Martin anymore, and that “the man has been done.”

The court described the killing this way. Martin was struck on the head with sudden force and then stabbed some 25 times in the upper body, head and neck. Hilton admitted to two acquaintances that he helped Holness by stabbing Martin several times with a knife Holness handed him, after Holness had struck and stabbed Martin. The Star reported later that the wounds included one at the back of the head, and that Martin was also hit with a barbell.

Black and white photo of murder victim John Martin

Hilton’s defence at trial was alibi and a denial of any part in the killing. At the close of the Crown’s case, his lawyer asked for a separate trial. Holness would not testify, and Hilton wanted to call him to support the alibi. The trial judge refused. In his charge, the judge reminded the jury of evidence of blood on Hilton’s pants, which Hilton washed the day after the death, and that the two men were “constant companions.” He also summarized the Crown’s theory. The two men planned to lure Martin to his apartment, have Holness test whether Martin would refuse to pay by having sex with him, and then kill him.

The jury found both men guilty of first-degree murder in December 1982. The Globe and Mail’s court list dates the conviction December 9. Mr. Justice William Parker sentenced each to life in prison with no chance of parole for 25 years, The Body Politic reported.

The Body Politic reported the verdict in an item that also covered a second case. On December 6, a jury found Andrew Guy Ritchie, 23, guilty of second-degree murder in the death of Marlon McCrae, 42, a controller for MCA Records, on March 1, 1981. Ritchie testified that he became angry when McCrae ran his fingers through his hair and suggested sex.

Holness and Hilton appealed. The Court of Appeal heard argument on November 28, 1984. On Tuesday, February 19, 1985, Holness was stabbed to death at Millhaven penitentiary near Kingston. About 70 prisoners were returning from the exercise yard, and Holness was still in his hockey uniform, the Star reported. On March 21, Ontario Provincial Police charged Hilton with first-degree murder in Holness’s death.

On April 17, 1985, the Court of Appeal released its decision. Mr. Justice Dubin wrote it for himself and Justices Blair and Cory. Holness’s appeal was quashed because he had died. Hilton’s appeal was dismissed, but his verdict was changed. The Crown’s case for first-degree murder rested on statements Holness made before and after the killing. Those statements were made in Hilton’s absence and could not be used against him. Nothing in Hilton’s own admissions showed planning and deliberation, the court said, and planning and deliberation must come before the first blow. The way the issue was left with the jury was “pure speculation.” The court substituted a verdict of second-degree murder. The life sentence stood. The Star later reported that Hilton’s parole ineligibility had been reduced to 12 years.

On November 5, 1985, the Star reported that Hilton had pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in Holness’s death. Crown counsel Rhys Morgan told the court that Hilton attacked Holness as he left the ice during a hockey game. Mr. Justice Gregory Evans sentenced Hilton to life in prison and ordered him to serve at least 15 years before parole, five more than the minimum.

The record varies on several points. The Star gave Holness’s age as 23, 24, 26 and 27, and Hilton’s as 22, 23, 24 and 25. The Body Politic, in early 1983, dated the killing “on or around Nov 14.” The Star’s reports place Martin alive at about 10:30 p.m. on Sunday, November 15, and found dead early Monday, November 16. The Globe and Mail called the trial judge Associate Chief Justice Parker. The Body Politic called him Mr. Justice William Parker.

Vital statistics

FieldDetail
NameJohn Henry Martin (printed once as “John Henry Miller” in the Toronto Star)
Age33
GenderMale
OccupationHairdresser (unemployed)
Date of deathNight of November 15–16, 1981; found early Monday, November 16
Manner of deathStab wounds and blows to the head
LocationSixth-floor apartment, 550 Jarvis Street, Toronto
AccusedEdward Michael Holness (reported as 23 to 27) and Gary Michael Hilton (reported as 22 to 25)
ChargeFirst-degree murder
Defence counselOn appeal: Alan D. Gold (Holness) and Brian H. Greenspan (Hilton)
Crown counselGlen Orr (trial); Ian A. MacDonnell (appeal)
JudgeWilliam Parker (trial); Dubin, Blair and Cory, JJ.A. (appeal)
VerdictBoth guilty of first-degree murder, December 1982. On appeal, Hilton’s verdict became second-degree murder; Holness’s appeal was quashed after his death.
SentenceLife, no parole eligibility for 25 years (December 1982). Hilton’s parole ineligibility was reduced to 12 years on appeal.

Sources

  • Toronto Star, November 16, 1981, p. 1
  • Toronto Star, November 17, 1981, p. A6
  • The Body Politic, December 1981, p. 10
  • The Body Politic, January/February 1982
  • Toronto Star, December 3, 1981, p. C15
  • Toronto Star, January 23, 1982, p. A5
  • Toronto Star, March 18, 1982, p. A6
  • The Globe and Mail, July 14, 1982, p. 5
  • Toronto Star, November 10, 1982, p. C15
  • The Body Politic, January/February 1983, p. 15
  • Toronto Star, February 21, 1985, p. A17
  • Toronto Star, March 22, 1985, p. E7
  • The Globe and Mail, April 18, 1985, p. B8
  • R. v. Holness and Hilton (1985), 7 O.A.C. 372 (Ont. C.A.), April 17, 1985: http://ca.vlex.com/vid/r-v-holness-681085537
  • Toronto Star, November 5, 1985, p. A8

 


Murder Village Map

 

 

2 thoughts on “John Henry Martin – Jarvis Street Stabbing”

  1. I know this was a very long time ago as I was living in Toronto at that time. Also, I knew John Martin (Jason) as he was a good friend of mine. I even shared an apartment with him for a short while. I do remember when this happened, such a shame and he was a lovely person.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.