David Murphy – Hammer and Electrical Cord

David Murphy, 1981, Lawrence Avenue East

David Murphy, 61, was found dead in his bedroom at Brimley Acres, a senior citizens’ apartment building at 2950 Lawrence Avenue East in Scarborough, on Monday, June 29, 1981. The Toronto Star reported that the superintendent found him after Murphy did not answer his phone. The Body Politic reported that police found the body just … Read more

Marlon J. McCrae – Killed by Homicidal ‘Drag Hooker’

Marlon McRae, 1981, Wynford Heights Crescent

The Toronto Star reported that a resident of an apartment building at 35 Wynford Heights Crescent, in North York, found a man lying in a pool of blood just inside the doors of the underground garage. It was about 4:45 on the morning of Sunday, March 1, 1981. The man had been stabbed several times … Read more

James Edward Downing – You Killed For That?

James Downing, 1979, Ontario Street

Early on Friday, October 26, 1979, the building superintendent let a 15-year-old girl into her brother’s apartment on Ontario Street. The Globe and Mail reported that she had failed to reach him by telephone. She found the body of James Edward Downing, 23, lying on a bed. Police said he had died of a stab … Read more

Diane Edwards – No Clear Motive

Diane Edwards, 1979, Badgerow Avenue

On the evening of Saturday, October 20, 1979, Micheline Ferland, 25, spoke to the Toronto Star on the steps of a house on Badgerow Avenue in east-end Toronto. Her left arm had been broken by a baseball bat that morning. “He was after Diane in particular,” she said. Diane Edwards was 36. At about 4:30 … Read more

James Macdonald – Murderous Love

James MacDonald, 1979, King Street West

On Monday, April 9, 1979, David Albert Manship went to a Toronto lawyer. The information he gave led police to the body of James MacDonald. MacDonald, 35, had been shot once with a sawed-off .22-calibre rifle. The Globe and Mail reported that he was found in Manship’s apartment on King Street West. The Toronto Star … Read more

James Francis McIntyre – Nine Stab Wounds

James McIntyre, 1979, Gifford Street

Early on Sunday, March 18, 1979, James Francis McIntyre was stabbed repeatedly in the head and body with a 10½-inch knife. Police arrested his roommate at the scene, in the Gerrard St. E.–Sackville St. area, and charged him with attempted murder. McIntyre died at Wellesley Hospital 13½ hours after the stabbing, the Toronto Star reported. … Read more

Duncan William Robinson – A Strange, Hollow Sound

William Robinson, 1978, Vaughan Road

On Tuesday, November 28, 1978, Duncan Robinson failed to turn up for work for the second day in a row. His sister, Catherine, asked police to check on him. Officers forced their way into his apartment on Vaughan Rd. and found his body in the bedroom. Toronto police records give the time of the call … Read more

Gerald Douglas White – Flowers and Feathers

Gerald White, 1978, Rosehill Avenue

Early on Monday, September 18, 1978, Gerald Douglas White was found in a pool of blood in a 15th-floor apartment on Rosehill Avenue in Toronto. The apartment belonged to a friend who was away on holiday. White had been looking after it, the Toronto Sun reported, visiting every day to check the security and feed … Read more

Shirley Hauser – Swimming Leads To Murder

Shirley Hauser, 1978, Evelyn Crescent

At 7:05 a.m. on Saturday, August 19, 1978, Nick Yasynowycz, 69, was walking his dog across the grounds of Western Technical-Commercial School on Evelyn Crescent. Near a flower bed on the west side of the school, he saw someone lying on her side. “I thought she was asleep at first,” he told the Sunday Star. … Read more

Donald Rochester – Victim Was An Assailant

Donald Rochester, 1978, Price Street

At about seven on the morning of Monday, February 13, 1978, Bill Petkos arrived for work at the Toronto Lawn Tennis Club on Price Street. On the second floor he found his co-worker Donald Rochester dead. Rochester had been shot in the head. He was wearing only his undershirt. The rest of his clothes were … Read more

Brian Dana Latocki – Tied and Tortured

Brian Latocki, 1977, Erskine Avenue

At about 9:40 a.m. on Tuesday, January 25, 1977, Toronto police answered a call to check an address at 141 Erskine Avenue. A young bank employee had not come to work, and the apartment superintendent had been asked to look in on him. Police found Brian Latocki dead in his bedroom. He was nude and … Read more

Hugh Thomas Armstrong – Prince Arthur Avenue Strangling

On October 9, 1976, friends went to the Prince Arthur Avenue apartment of Hugh Thomas Armstrong after he failed to show up for work. The Toronto Sun reported that they found his body on the bedroom floor, in a bathrobe. The Globe and Mail reported that he lay face down and that the apartment had … Read more

Carmen Noel Allgrove – Rage At Rejection

Carmen Allgrove, 1976, King Street East

On the afternoon of Saturday, September 4, 1976, a man from Cooksville was walking through the bush near Enterprise Hill, looking for mushrooms. The spot was on the east side of Highway 115, north of Newcastle and about 60 miles east of Toronto. He came upon two garbage bags and ripped one open. Then he … Read more

James Douglas Taylor – Unsolved Baseball Bat Murder

James Taylor, 1976, Elmhurst Avenue

On the morning of Wednesday, February 11, 1976, a young man went to a rented bungalow on Elmhurst Avenue in Willowdale. He had lived in the house himself until about seven months earlier. He found James Douglas Taylor dead in the bedroom. The Toronto Police Service file records a call at about 10:20 a.m., and … Read more

Samuel McClelland – Homophobic Hatred

Samuel McClelland, 1969, Eastern Avenue

Early on Sunday, June 15, 1969, a man’s body was found in a parking lot on Eastern Avenue. He lay between a parked car and a truck, behind an auto lubricating firm at Eastern and Empire Avenues. He had been struck repeatedly on the face and head. The lot was part of a block owned … Read more